Some­times, par­tic­u­larly in a pub­lic par­ent­ing set­ting, I will play the Bet­ter Mother. This is the mother who stands at­ten­tively out­side a mu­sic au­di­tion, se­renely lis­ten­ing to the notes em­a­nat­ing from within. She re­al­izes the par­ent next to her said “Haydn,” not “Biden.”

When her child emerges, the Bet­ter Mother isn’t sprawled on the floor play­ing Spelling Bee, but in­stead greets him with en­cour­ag­ing com­men­tary on the sec­ond move­ment. Also, she has brought a snack.

The Bet­ter Mother su­cceeds

The Bet­ter Mother un­der­stands the la­crosse match (game?), cheer­ing at ap­pro­pri­ate mo­ments in ways that hearten rather than hu­mil­i­ate. She knows the coach and chats ami­a­bly with team par­ents about var­i­ous ma­neu­ver­ings on the field, nim­bly ex­pand­ing the con­ver­sa­tion to school com­mit­tees and af­ter-school events. She did not bring a book.

The Bet­ter Mother en­sures that her kids have dress shoes that aren’t two sizes too small. She bakes. She reads of­fi­cial emails from school and camp from be­gin­ning to end. She knows which teach­ers your kids are sup­posed to get and whom to email if they aren’t got­ten. She al­ways brings a wa­ter bot­tle.

Advertise with us

She is not the mother who didn’t know there was a school con­cert and has to sneak in as the lights go down. She knows which side of the field her child is play­ing on and pos­si­bly which po­si­tion. She never texts at a stop­light with her child in the car.

She is em­pathic but not over­bear­ing, af­fec­tion­ate but not trea­cly, wise but not smug, con­cerned but not anx­ious. She is the mother who knows dan­ger but never checks in on a child for the wrong rea­son.

The Bet­ter Mother is, by def­i­ni­tion, a bet­ter mother than I am. She can be a to­tal stranger spot­ted at the mu­seum or a fa­mil­iar face at a birth­day party. Either way, she is a nat­u­ral star in the play for which you ha­ven’t quite mem­o­rized your lines.

Most moth­ers — and fathers — prob­a­bly have a per­sonal vi­sion of their own com­pe­ti­tion, de­pend­ing on one’s skill set or lack thereof. For me, it de­pends on the con­text, my mood, the child in ques­tion and the spec­trum of pa­ren­tal fig­ures in the vi­cin­ity, even some­times on which TV show I last watched or what book I’m read­ing.

Play­ing the part

For a pe­riod, I de­cided that a bet­ter mother than I was Mary-Kay Wilmers, a for­mer ed­i­tor of The Lon­don Review of Books. I’ve never met her, but read about her in “Love, Nina,” a mem­oir by Nina Stibbe, who served as a nanny to Wilmers’ two pre­co­cious sons.

Advertise with us

Wilmers sur­rounded her chil­dren with clever Brit­ish em­i­nences such as play­wright and nov­el­ist Alan Ben­nett and bi­og­ra­pher Claire Toma­lin, as well as Amer­i­can critic John Lahr. Raised among bril­liance, her boys be­came sharp wits them­selves, bit­ing and slightly wicked in their hu­mor.

As I didn’t have any sto­ried lit­er­ary fig­ures light­ing up my din­ner ta­ble, I sim­ply let loose all my own most caus­tic com­ments, the kinds of un­char­i­ta­ble thoughts you usu­ally re­serve for like-minded adults. Alas, with­out el­e­gant Brit­ish com­pan­ions, I was merely en­cour­ag­ing a rude sar­casm.

My er­ror was high­lighted in the pres­ence of an­other Bet­ter Mother, my friend Robin, whose chil­dren looked strang­ers in the eye upon meet­ing, shook hands firmly and man­aged civ­i­lized nice­ties.

No one is sug­gest­ing you have to be the Bet­ter Mother — merely that you can play her in pub­lic at your dis­cre­tion. When you’re sur­rounded by a bunch of slacker par­ents or all-out bad moms or you’ve had a busy week and need an ex­tra boost, you can sim­ply slip on the role, ide­ally in pub­lic, for a Sun­day af­ter­noon. Yes, I am say­ing you can fake it.

Mother’s Day brings forth the Bet­ter Moth­ers in droves, when they ac­cept all due ad­u­la­tion. On such oc­ca­sions, re­gard­less of what kind of mother you are in re­al­ity, you can damn well play the part.

Advertise with us

The real judges

And who’s go­ing to be the wiser? The ones we think of as Bet­ter Moth­ers could be big fak­ers them­selves, women who shove un­evenly mi­cro­waved Trader Joe’s items be­fore their kids for din­ner and call it a night.

They could be the ones who post about their teen­agers on TikTok or slap their tod­dlers in Tar­get when an iPhone cam­era isn’t in the vi­cin­ity.

Or they could just be like most par­ents, oc­ca­sion­ally too tired to read aloud, not hugely in­ter­ested in sev­enth-grade al­ge­bra or sim­ply not in the mood to play.

It is pos­si­ble the Bet­ter Moth­ers are no bet­ter than the rest of us. Only our chil­dren know the truth.

Pamela Paul is a columnist for The New York Times. Her previous article was “Our golden age of aggrievement.”