Stu­dent pro­test move­ments in Amer­ica are of­ten messy and di­vi­sive, but they tend to be on the right side of his­tory. If Pres­i­dent Joe Biden doesn’t take the anti-war pro­tests more se­ri­ously, he is likely to end up on the wrong side of his­tory and the No­vem­ber elec­tion as well.

From the Vi­et­nam War and civil rights move­ments in the 1960s to the anti-apart­heid pro­tests of the 1980s and Black Lives Mat­ter in 2020, these ef­forts sought to tackle the role of U.S. in­sti­tu­tions and gov­ern­ment in per­pet­u­at­ing in­justices.

Vindi­cated pro­tests

Many might de­test their meth­od­ol­ogy, and we should all clearly op­pose vi­o­lence or hate speech within their ranks, but the broad causes are just and his­tor­i­cally vin­di­cated.

These pro­tests will be vin­di­cated too. Amer­ica’s young peo­ple are not alone in op­pos­ing con­tin­ued U.S. sup­port of Is­rael’s ac­tions in Gaza. A Gallup poll re­leased in March showed that 55% of Amer­i­cans to­day dis­ap­prove of it — a shift from the be­gin­ning of the war, when most Amer­i­cans wanted the U.S. gov­ern­ment to ro­bustly sup­port Is­rael’s war ef­forts.

Advertise with us

For those who ask why stu­dents aren’t pro­test­ing Ha­mas, it’s be­cause these in­sti­tu­tions aren’t sup­port­ing or help­ing fi­nance the ter­ror­ist group.

Across the coun­try, stu­dent groups are spe­cif­i­cally tar­get­ing their col­leges and uni­ver­sities, where they ex­pect their in­flu­ence will be great­est, call­ing on them to di­vest funds from cor­po­ra­tions and busi­nesses that sup­port Is­rael’s mil­i­tary ac­tion. Spe­cific calls to ac­tion vary, from di­vest­ing from any com­pa­nies and in­sti­tu­tions linked to Is­rael to any com­pa­nies linked to arms man­u­fac­tur­ing gen­er­ally.

The ob­sta­cles

This ap­proach most closely echoes the pro­tests against South Africa’s apart­heid gov­ern­ment, which are cred­ited with push­ing 155 uni­ver­sities to di­vest from com­pa­nies that sup­ported or prof­ited from apart­heid and the U.S. gov­ern­ment to en­act a di­vest­ment pol­icy as well.

But stu­dent de­mands to­day face more ob­sta­cles. Op­po­si­tion to Is­raeli gov­ern­ment ac­tion is far more po­lar­iz­ing than op­po­si­tion to the South African apart­heid re­gime was then. Po­lit­i­cal sup­port for Is­rael within the U.S. sys­tem is so strong that it has se­cured laws in more than 30 states that pro­hibit state gov­ern­ments from do­ing busi­ness with com­pa­nies that pro­mote di­vest­ment from Is­rael.

This could prove a real chal­lenge for ed­u­ca­tional in­sti­tu­tions even if they are open to pro­tester de­mands. Univer­sity ad­min­is­tra­tors are al­ready fac­ing loud crit­i­cism from Re­pub­li­can po­lit­i­cal lead­ers in Wash­ing­ton who are call­ing on some to re­sign. Nav­i­gat­ing the di­vide be­tween free speech and hate speech is par­tic­u­larly fraught in light of the his­tory of an­tisem­i­tism in our coun­try and be­yond.

Advertise with us

While most of the pro­test­ers across the coun­try ap­pear to be peace­ful, it’s a ripe space for agi­ta­tors, par­tic­u­larly those who hope to soil pub­lic per­cep­tions of the pro­tests for po­lit­i­cal gain.

But ob­serv­ers should not let the ex­treme ac­tors or de­trac­tors cloud the im­por­tant mes­sage these stu­dents are try­ing to send: The sit­u­a­tion in Gaza is in­hu­mane and un­ten­able, and those in a po­si­tion to do some­thing about it must act.

Thought­ful con­ver­sa­tion

No one ex­pects uni­ver­sity of­fi­cials to be able to end the war, and no one de­nies Is­rael’s right to de­fend it­self. But it’s rea­son­able to ex­pect a thought­ful con­ver­sa­tion about whether these uni­ver­sities can do more to en­sure they aren’t help­ing per­pet­u­ate dis­pro­por­tion­ate ci­vil­ian harm.

Univer­sities would be smart to agree to meet the stu­dents with greater trans­par­ency and di­a­logue in­stead of with force.

Stu­dent ac­tiv­ists might learn from this ex­pe­ri­ence too. Oth­er­wise, like the Vi­et­nam pro­tests of 1968, these demon­stra­tions could help usher in a pres­i­dent far less sen­si­tive to their con­cerns.

Elizabeth Shackelford is is the Magro Family Distinguished Visitor in International Affairs at Dartmouth College and a foreign affairs columnist for the Chicago Tribune. Her previous article was “The world ignores suffering as bad as Gaza's and Ukraine's.”