Here’s a nag­ging worry for of­fi­cials in the U.S., Europe and the wider West: Is post-Gaza and post-Mos­cow also pre-Olym­pics? I’m talk­ing about the threat of ter­ror­ism, es­pe­cially in an­tic­i­pa­tion of soft tar­gets such as the up­com­ing sum­mer games in Paris.

The sa­dis­tic at­tack by Ha­mas against Is­rael on Oct. 7 was so “suc­cess­ful” from a ji­ha­dist’s point of view, it might re-en­er­gize other ter­ror­ist groups. The death and suf­fer­ing in the Gaza Strip caused by the mas­sive Is­raeli re­tal­i­a­tion are now rad­i­cal­iz­ing a new gen­er­a­tion of Muslims, some of whom may en­list in what­ever form ter­ror­ist ji­hadism takes.

The ter­ror­ist threats

The re­cent and deadly as­sault on a con­cert hall in Mos­cow by ISIS-K, opened yet an­other front in the global ji­ha­dist threat. Some Amer­i­can top brass be­lieve that the U.S. “re­mains tar­get No. 1” for this group.

If ter­ror­ism was Wash­ing­ton’s pri­or­ity in the years fol­low­ing Sept. 11, 2001, it has in re­cent years lost sa­lience rel­a­tive to other na­tional-se­cu­rity threats, es­pe­cially the more tra­di­tional men­ace of hos­tile states with armies and nukes, such as China, Rus­sia or North Korea.

Advertise with us

In this year’s An­nual Threat Assess­ment of the U.S. In­tel­li­gence Com­mu­nity, ter­ror­ism shows up on page 38 out of 40, be­hind prob­lems such as fen­ta­nyl, money laun­der­ing, cy­ber crime and hu­man traf­fick­ing.

That is proof not of ne­glect but of the West’s rel­a­tive suc­cess. The U.S. and its al­lies spent years de­grad­ing net­works such as Al-Qaeda and the Islamic State and kill­ing their lead­ers. The lat­ter no lon­ger con­trols any ter­ri­tory in its for­mer cra­dle of Iraq and Syria, even if off­shoots such as ISIS-K carry on else­where.

In­tel­li­gence ser­vices have also be­come much more adept at spy­ing out and dis­rupt­ing plots. (The US, as well as Iran, warned the Krem­lin about the ISIS-K plot, but was ig­nored.)

No­body can rule out a re­sur­gence of ter­ror­ism. That said, a lot sug­gests that ji­hadism, at least in the West, will keep evolv­ing into a man­age­able threat, thinks Barak Men­del­sohn of Hav­er­ford Col­lege. Even if the num­ber of Isla­mist ter­ror­ist groups is grow­ing, he told me, they’re also more frag­mented than net­works such as Al-Qaeda used to be in the 1990s, and of­ten hate one an­other as much as they ex­e­crate the US.

ISIS-K hates ev­ery­one

Take ISIS-K again. It loathes the Tal­i­ban, its ri­vals for power in Af­ghan­istan. It also hates all groups af­fil­i­ated with Shia Islam, from Yemen’s Houthis to Leb­a­non’s Hez­bol­lah and Iran’s mul­lahs, all of whom it con­sid­ers apos­tates.

Advertise with us

It de­tests all states it views as hos­tile to Sun­nis, in­clud­ing Rus­sia (which has propped up a Shia dic­ta­tor in Syria and part­nered with Te­hran) as well as China (which bru­tally sup­presses the Sunni Uyghurs in its Xin­jiang Prov­ince). And it hates what Men­del­sohn calls the “near en­emy” — that is, the lo­cal re­gimes in places such as Ta­jik­i­stan that it wants to con­quer and con­vert to its ca­liph­ate.

The “far en­emy” in the U.S. thus has a lot of com­pe­ti­tion as a tar­get. For ISIS-K, it’s far eas­ier to at­tack Iran, say, as it did in Jan­u­ary. (The U.S. had tipped off Te­hran about that strike too, just as it re­cently alerted Mos­cow.)

So the trend is away from trans­na­tional or global ter­ror­ism, in which ji­hadis try to build large net­works to go af­ter big tar­gets, in­clud­ing the US. In­stead, ter­ror­ist at­tacks in the West will prob­a­bly be smaller in scale, ex­e­cuted by sleeper cells or “lone wolves” — an alien­ated Muslim in Brus­sels, say, or Mich­i­gan.

In re­gions such as Africa’s Sa­hel, mean­while, ji­ha­dist vi­o­lence will me­tas­ta­size. In the power vac­uum of this re­gion’s failed states, a va­ri­ety of groups, only loosely af­fil­i­ated with trans­na­tional net­works such as the Islamic State, are fight­ing sun­dry en­e­mies, rang­ing from lo­cal re­gimes or jun­tas to ri­val clans, tribes and war­lords. The stra­te­gic threat to the West is more likely to take the form of con­tin­ued mass mi­gra­tion out of Africa than of cat­a­clys­mic ter­ror­ist at­tacks.

The geo­po­lit­i­cal trend from un­i­po­lar­ity in the 1990s to mul­ti­po­lar­ity in this cen­tury should also dif­fuse the ji­ha­dists’ for­mer fo­cus on the US. Rus­sia, China and Iran are at least as much in some ter­ror­ists’ cross­hairs as we are.

Advertise with us

Splin­ter­ing ji­hadism

The splin­ter­ing of global ji­hadism presents one op­por­tu­nity for the West to keep ter­ror­ism rel­a­tively man­age­able. The com­mon threat against all ma­jor pow­ers, in­clud­ing U.S. ad­ver­sar­ies such as Rus­sia and China, of­fers an­other.

If Bei­jing, say, can be per­suaded to co­op­er­ate against ter­ror­ism, this rec­i­proc­ity could po­ten­tially build trust for fu­ture talks about nu­clear arms con­trol or threat re­duc­tion in the Tai­wan Strait. That’s an­other rea­son for Wash­ing­ton to con­tinue warn­ing even en­e­mies about ter­ror­ist plots against them.

Like other evils, from white Suprem­acy to fen­ta­nyl, ter­ror­ism must be per­ma­nently con­tained and man­aged. But the old pat­tern of cy­cling be­tween com­pla­cency and over­re­ac­tion ap­pears to be bro­ken.

Andreas Kluth is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. His previous article was “America's growing break with Israel.”