Get mar­ried, have chil­dren, buy a house, and live com­fort­ably on a sin­gle in­come. Not very long ago, that path was the re­al­ity, the norm, for the great Amer­i­can mid­dle class. But Amer­ica has gone back­ward in this re­gard, and strug­gling cit­i­zens know it all too well.

Ex­pe­ri­enc­ing the kinds of lives en­joyed by our par­ents and grand­par­ents has be­come im­pos­sible for most Amer­i­cans, lead­ing to wide­spread dis­en­chant­ment and a pal­pa­ble loss of pa­tri­o­tism and con­fi­dence in Amer­ica.

Poll­ing proves this point. Last year, a Wall Street Jour­nal sur­vey found that 78% of Amer­i­cans do not be­lieve their chil­dren will be bet­ter off in the fu­ture, the least op­ti­mis­tic find­ing in the his­tory of that poll, which goes back de­cades. Sim­i­larly, an­other Wall Street Jour­nal sur­vey found that only 36% of Amer­i­cans be­lieve the Amer­i­can Dream is still achiev­able.

The dis­ad­van­taged non-wealthy

As bad as those poll re­sults are, they are per­haps too op­ti­mis­tic, at least for the key bat­tle­ground states that will de­cide the 2024 na­tional elec­tion. My pop­u­list-right la­bor­ers’ ad­vo­cacy group, the League of Amer­i­can Work­ers, sur­veys these swing states on a ro­tat­ing ba­sis. Our poll last No­vem­ber in bat­tle­ground Ari­zona dis­cov­ered that only 18% of likely vot­ers there think the Amer­i­can Dream is still at­tain­able.

Advertise with us

We just re­turned to Ari­zona to poll the state again, and the new re­sults point to the spe­cific pol­icy fail­ures that cre­ate seem­ingly in­sur­mount­able ob­sta­cles fac­ing hard-work­ing cit­i­zens there. Poll­ing firm North Star Opin­ion Re­search used an Ari­zona sam­ple evenly split be­tween Trump and Biden 2020 vot­ers and found that 84% said that a fam­ily can­not thrive on a sin­gle in­come. A whop­ping 88% said that af­ford­able hous­ing is out of reach for most cit­i­zens.

In a coun­try as po­lit­i­cally po­lar­ized as Amer­ica is pres­ently, many po­lit­i­cal is­sues break down in typ­i­cal 45%–45% splits. So, such near-unan­i­mous Ari­zona poll re­sults are star­tling. More­over, they point to sys­temic prob­lems.

To be sure, the trends that dis­ad­van­tage the non-wealthy masses have wors­ened for de­cades. Glo­bal­iza­tion, mass mi­gra­tion, and a fi­nan­cially cen­tered econ­omy have eroded the stan­dard of liv­ing for work­ing-class cit­i­zens since the 1970s. But these trends have also ac­cel­er­ated ma­teri­ally un­der Pres­i­dent Biden, and vot­ers clearly blame him for their pre­dic­a­ment, per our new poll­ing.

On the ques­tion of in­come, de­trac­tors might re­gard even ask­ing about sin­gle-in­come house­holds as some­how anach­ro­nis­tic or sex­ist. But sur­veys clearly re­veal that at least half of women with young chil­dren pre­fer to stay home — and su­per­ma­jor­i­ties pre­fer to have at least the op­tion to stay home.

What Amer­i­cans want

But whether the stay-at-home care­giver is the mother or the father, shouldn’t the op­tion to stay home be a laud­able eco­nomic goal for our so­ci­ety? Clearly, work­ing-class Amer­i­cans think so, as only 29% of blue-col­lar Amer­i­cans pre­fer both par­ents work­ing full time, per Amer­i­can Com­pass poll­ing.

Advertise with us

Regard­ing hous­ing af­ford­abil­ity, the av­er­age sales price for a home in the Phoe­nix area just hit an all-time record high at $590,000. Even the pro-Biden New York Times ac­knowl­edged this harsh eco­nomic re­al­ity with a sting­ing ar­ti­cle about the lack of hous­ing af­ford­abil­ity, not­ing: “Ari­zona is a pres­i­den­tial elec­tion bat­tle­ground state, and a dire short­age of af­ford­able hous­ing there is sow­ing eco­nomic anx­i­ety among vot­ers.”

Fully 87% of pledged Biden vot­ers in Ari­zona be­lieve af­ford­able hous­ing is out of reach. Other his­tor­i­cally Demo­cratic con­stit­u­en­cies con­cur, with 93% of young adults and 90% of His­pan­ics re­port­ing that hous­ing is not af­ford­able.

Un­do­ing de­cades of pol­icy fail­ures rep­resents a daunt­ing task, to be sure. But Amer­ica must again be­come a na­tion of prom­ise for work­ing-class fam­i­lies. Time to get to work on re­stor­ing that kind of so­ci­ety.

Steve Cortes is for­mer se­nior ad­vi­sor to Pres­i­dent Trump, for­mer com­men­tator for Fox News and CNN, and pres­i­dent of the League of Amer­i­can Work­ers.