With more than 60 countries with around 4.2 billion people holding elections in 2024, those running for office will undoubtedly focus on economic issues such as jobs, inflation and the cost of health care. All too few will focus on perhaps the most important component of economic success: entrepreneurial activity.

Entrepreneurial activity means the percentage of the adult population that has taken some action towards creating a new business in the past year, or who are owner-managers of an active business less than 42 months old. Entrepreneurship is the engine of economic development.

What government does

According to the World Economic Forum, at least four of the 13 conditions for a successful entrepreneurship economy are the direct responsibility of national governments. Governments can directly support the entrepreneurial process through the provision of resources and investments in research and development.

Advertise with us

In Israel, for example, the government promoted entrepreneurship by creating a venture capital industry to crowd-in private investments and build one of the most successful high-tech powerhouses outside the United States. However, the top-down formula of selecting a hot industry, building a science park next to a research university, creating a VC pool and providing subsidies for chosen industries in hundreds of other regions across the world has failed to recreate the same magic.

So, what makes a country entrepreneurial?

A democratic political system fosters private enterprise and wealth creation, whereas a centrally planned communist system hinders it. The level of economic development impacts the motivations for entrepreneurship. Per GEM, an average of 35% of entrepreneurs in low-income economies are necessity entrepreneurs who start up due to dissatisfaction with, or absence of, conventional work options rather than to exploit an opportunity. Hofstede's dimensions of “national” culture also determine the degree of enterprise. Indeed, professional networks between faculty and industry leaders and the culture of risk taking and learning from failure have lent Silicon Valley a unique advantage compared to other regional clusters even within the United States, like Boston.

Notwithstanding some possible generalizations, direct comparisons of the international environment for entrepreneurship are complex.

First, each economy has its own profile comprising both enablers as well as challenges. Whereas a strong economy bodes well for Japan, for example, in terms of the availability of support resources for early-stage start-up activity, a collectivist culture that penalizes risk-taking mars entrepreneurial initiative.

Advertise with us

Second, the goals of entrepreneurship vary across countries. Whereas innovation in developed economies is often synonymous with technology entrepreneurship, in developing economies like Asia and Africa, it’s often associated with social innovation.

Third, entrepreneurial activity manifests at various levels, especially where external conditions for mainstream enterprise are far from ideal. Whereas independent start-ups are often most studied and analyzed in the West, entrepreneurship in collectivist Asian countries like China assumes the form of large organizations and family businesses.

So, what can be done to make countries entrepreneurial? First, governments need to recognize that no one size fits all. It is important to examine each national or regional context prior to blindly replicating a foreign ecosystem.

Second, while initiatives like establishing research universities or lending financial support to launch new ventures may be necessary, they are not sufficient. Support infrastructure like incubation, social networks, and information and communication technologies are needed to scale up new ventures.

Migration and culture

Advertise with us

Openness to inward and return migration can help attract talent to identify and exploit opportunities and build global networks regardless of geography.

Relatedly, and most critical perhaps, is the need to create a culture conducive for innovation. A culture that questions, rather than accepts, the status quo and rewards, rather than penalizes, risk-taking and experimentation is necessary to instill confidence for new venture creation.

Sarika Pruthi is an associate professor of entrepreneurship at the Lucas School of Business, San Jose State University, and a public voices fellow with The OpEd Project.