Learn­ing from your mis­takes isn’t just some­thing that ap­plies to your per­sonal life — it’s a core les­son of po­lit­i­cal sci­ence. Ten years be­fore the Fram­ers of our Con­sti­tu­tion gath­ered in Phil­a­del­phia to draft a new gov­ern­ing doc­u­ment, they adopted the Ar­ti­cles of Con­fed­er­a­tion.

Our Found­ing Fathers were so as­sured of its suc­cess that they in­tended it to last in per­pe­tu­ity. For­ever, in this case, was a de­cade.

Learning from their mistakes

The Fram­ers re­al­ized that their best ef­fort to de­sign a work­able gov­ern­ment clashed with the ne­ces­si­ties of a chang­ing na­tion. Here’s a short list of choices they quickly came to re­gret.

Advertise with us

First, Con­gress op­er­ated like the United Na­tions. Rep­re­sen­ta­tives were paid and se­lected by states. Un­sur­pris­ingly, this led to rep­re­sen­ta­tives hav­ing lit­tle to no in­ter­est in sup­port­ing any leg­is­la­tion that neg­a­tively af­fected their re­spec­tive states.

Second, they vested all power in a sin­gle branch of gov­ern­ment; their con­cern about a sin­gle ex­ec­u­tive (think King George) hav­ing too much power led them to avoid cre­at­ing an ex­ec­u­tive branch and to in­stead place all power in the leg­is­la­tive branch.

Third, even if the peo­ple re­al­ized a need to amend the Ar­ti­cles they could only do so upon all states agree­ing to the change; as you may imag­ine, reach­ing con­sen­sus among 13 states is nearly im­pos­sible.

For­tu­nately for us, the Ar­ti­cles did not last for eter­nity. The Fram­ers rel­a­tively quickly learned from their mis­takes. They ral­lied to vastly im­prove upon their first go at cre­at­ing a coun­try.

The sec­ond time around they in­cen­tivized our rep­re­sen­ta­tives to think na­tion­ally as well as lo­cally; they cre­ated three branches of gov­ern­ment and re­duced their odds of con­cen­trat­ing power by de­vel­op­ing a se­ries of checks and bal­ances; and, they low­ered the thresh­old to amend the Con­sti­tu­tion.

Advertise with us

That rapid pace of learn­ing, though, has not car­ried into the 21st cen­tury. Con­sider that we’re cur­rently in the third lon­gest drought be­tween con­sti­tu­tional amend­ments. Sixty-one years passed be­tween the rat­i­fi­ca­tion of the 12th and 13th amend­ments; af­ter the 15th Amend­ment, it took an­other 43 years be­fore the rat­i­fi­ca­tion of the 16th; and it has been more than de­cades since we rat­i­fied the 27th Amend­ment in 1992.

In the in­terim, na­tions around the world have taken mean­ing­ful steps to im­prove their de­moc­ra­cies – their re­forms, min­i­mally, de­serve close scru­tiny from all those who want Amer­i­can de­moc­racy to re­main as rep­re­sen­ta­tive, de­lib­er­a­tive and re­spon­sive as pos­si­ble.

Five amendments

Thank­fully, a group of schol­ars from across the po­lit­i­cal spec­trum has al­ready done a lot of our demo­cratic home­work for us. Con­vened by the Na­tional Con­sti­tu­tion Center in 2022, this group closely stud­ied ways Amer­ica can im­prove our de­moc­racy by learn­ing not only from our past but also from the demo­cratic en­deav­ors of other coun­tries.

Despite their ide­o­log­i­cal dif­fer­ences, these con­sti­tu­tional ex­perts reached con­sen­sus on five po­ten­tial amend­ments to the Con­sti­tu­tion:

Advertise with us

First, elim­i­nat­ing the nat­u­ral-born cit­i­zen re­quire­ment for an in­di­vid­ual to serve as pres­i­dent. In an age of glo­bal­iza­tion, why not al­low the most qual­i­fied can­di­dates to run for any of­fice – re­gard­less of whether they were born here or choose Amer­ica to be their home?

Second, mak­ing it a bit eas­ier to amend­ the Con­sti­tu­tion. At a time of novel and sig­nifi­cant prob­lems aris­ing, it makes sense to in­crease the odds of re­spon­sive and re­spon­si­ble ad­just­ments to the Con­sti­tu­tion, right?

Third, pro­vid­ing Con­gress with the chance to veto agency rules prior to their en­act­ment. Such a “leg­is­la­tive veto” was a pop­u­lar means for Con­gress to check the ad­min­is­tra­tive state prior to the Supreme Court de­clar­ing the prac­tice un­con­sti­tu­tional.

Fourth, clar­i­fy­ing when and how of­fi­cials may be im­peached — a con­sti­tu­tional law ques­tion that has puz­zled schol­ars for de­cades, if not cen­tu­ries.

And, fifth, im­pos­ing an 18-year term limit on Supreme Court justices. Given the in­creas­ing im­por­tance of Supreme Court de­ci­sions on so­cial, po­lit­i­cal and eco­nomic af­fairs, this change may help re­store faith in this es­sen­tial in­sti­tu­tion.

Advertise with us

Constitutional experimentation

You may agree with all of these or none of these amend­ments — that’s fine. These sug­ges­tions — reached by an ide­o­log­i­cally di­verse set of re­ally smart peo­ple – are not in­tended to open and close the con­ver­sa­tion on how to make sure our Con­sti­tu­tion has the checks and bal­ances re­quired by the 21st cen­tury.

Let’s in­stead use this list of five to re­vive our will­ing­ness to closely study the health of our de­moc­racy, our Con­sti­tu­tion and our po­lit­i­cal com­mu­nity. Though the Con­sti­tu­tion it­self is surely one of the great­est gifts left by its Fram­ers, even more valu­able is the gift of their ex­am­ple of demo­cratic ex­per­i­men­ta­tion.

Kevin Frazier teaches at the Crump College of Law at St. Thomas University. His previous article was “The big guys use the middle guy to hurt the average guy.”