In his State of the Union ad­dress, Pres­i­dent Biden called out “mas­sive ex­ec­u­tive pay” and vowed to “make big cor­po­ra­tions and the very wealthy finally pay their share” of taxes. Cor­po­rate tax dodg­ing and CEO pay have got­ten so out of con­trol that many ma­jor U.S. com­pa­nies are pay­ing their top ex­ec­u­tives more than they’re pay­ing Un­cle Sam.

Te­sla is per­haps the most dra­matic ex­am­ple. From 2018 to 2022, the com­pany raked in $4.4 bil­lion in prof­its but paid no fed­eral in­come taxes. Mean­while, Te­sla CEO Elon Musk be­came one of the world’s rich­est men.

Less in taxes, more to ex­ecs

When it comes to fleec­ing tax­pay­ers while over­pay­ing ex­ec­u­tives, Te­sla is hardly alone. A new re­port we co-au­thored for the In­sti­tute for Pol­icy Studies and Amer­i­cans for Tax Fair­ness an­a­lyzes ex­ec­u­tive pay data for some of the coun­try’s most no­to­ri­ous cor­po­rate tax dodgers.

Advertise with us

What did we find? In ad­di­tion to Te­sla, 34 other large and prof­it­able U.S. firms — in­clud­ing house­hold names like Ford, Net­flix, and T-Mo­bile — paid less in fed­eral in­come taxes be­tween 2018 and 2022 than they paid their top five ex­ec­u­tives.

Another 29 prof­it­able cor­po­ra­tions paid their top ex­ec­u­tives more than they paid Un­cle Sam in at least two of the five years of the study pe­riod.

One com­pany on our list stands out for the in­fa­mous role its ex­ec­u­tives played in the 2008 fi­nan­cial cri­sis: Amer­i­can In­ter­na­tional Group. Back then, the in­sur­ance gi­ant ig­nited a fire­storm by pock­et­ing a $180 bil­lion tax­payer bail­out and then an­nounc­ing plans to hand out $165 mil­lion in bo­nuses to the very same ex­ec­u­tives re­spon­si­ble for push­ing the com­pany — and the na­tion — to the brink of col­lapse.

To­day, AIG is play­ing the same greedy game of over­pay­ing its top brass and stick­ing tax­pay­ers with the bill. Between 2018 and 2022, the com­pany paid its top five ex­ec­u­tives more than it paid in fed­eral in­come taxes, de­spite col­lect­ing $17.7 bil­lion in U.S. prof­its. In 2022, CEO Peter Zaffino alone made $75 mil­lion.

Tax cuts and wind­falls

Advertise with us

Lav­ish ex­ec­u­tive com­pen­sa­tion pack­ages and skimpy cor­po­rate tax pay­ments are not un­re­lated. Ex­ec­u­tives have a huge per­sonal in­cen­tive to hire armies of lob­by­ists to push for cor­po­rate tax cuts be­cause the wind­falls from these cuts of­ten wind up in their own pock­ets.

The 2017 Re­pub­li­can tax law slashed the cor­po­rate tax rate from 35% to 21% and failed to close loop­holes that whit­tle down IRS bills even fur­ther. Many large, prof­it­able cor­po­ra­tions ended up pay­ing no fed­eral taxes at all.

Cor­po­ra­tions took the sav­ings from those tax cuts and spent a record-break­ing $1 tril­lion on stock buy­backs, a fi­nan­cial ma­neu­ver that ar­ti­fi­cially in­flates the value of ex­ec­u­tives’ stock-based pay.

Wealthy ex­ec­u­tives be­came even wealth­ier while the na­tion lost bil­lions of dol­lars in cor­po­rate rev­e­nue that could have been used to lower costs and im­prove ser­vices for or­di­nary peo­ple. Un­til this self-re­in­forc­ing cy­cle is bro­ken, we’ll have a cor­po­rate tax and com­pen­sa­tion sys­tem that works for top ex­ec­u­tives — and no one else.

What can we do to break this cy­cle?

Advertise with us

Con­gress can tackle the en­twined prob­lems of in­ad­e­quate cor­po­rate tax pay­ments and ex­cess ex­ec­u­tive pay on sev­eral fronts. Rais­ing the cor­po­rate tax rate to 28% (just half­way back to Obama-era lev­els) would gen­er­ate $1.3 tril­lion in new rev­e­nue over the next de­cade.

Close the loop­holes

Con­gress must also close loop­holes and elim­i­nate waste­ful tax breaks, for in­stance by re­mov­ing the in­cen­tives for Amer­i­can firms to shift prof­its and pro­duc­tion off­shore. Pol­i­cy­mak­ers also have a wealth of tools to curb ex­ces­sive ex­ec­u­tive pay, from tax and con­tract­ing re­forms to stron­ger reg­u­la­tions to rein in stock buy­backs and banker bo­nuses.

We know we need change when cor­po­ra­tions are re­ward­ing a hand­ful of top ex­ec­u­tives more than they are con­trib­ut­ing to the cost of pub­lic ser­vices needed for our econ­omy to thrive.

Sarah Anderson directs the Global Economy Project and co-edits Inequality.org at the Institute for Policy Studies. William Rice is a senior writer and Zachary Tashman is a Senior Research and Policy Associate at Americans for Tax Fairness.