An unromantic comedy, Adelle Waldman’s 2013 novel “The Love Affairs of Nathaniel P.” is a note-perfect depiction of Obama-era literary Brooklyn and the Ivy-educated cads who think of themselves as sensitive and enlightened even as they treat women as disposable.

It was a big hit, but instead of capitalizing on her sudden stardom, Waldman didn’t publish another novel for more than a decade. “I just didn’t have another idea,” she told me. So in 2018, not knowing what to write about instead, she got a job unloading trucks at a nearby Target, vaguely hoping to find inspiration in the lives of people far outside her own milieu.

An unknown universe

The result is the poignant, funny, stealthily ambitious “Help Wanted,” which follows a group of low-wage part-time employees at a Target-like big box store as they scheme to rid themselves of their toxic manager and secure a promotion for one of their own. It depicts a universe that my privileged cohort encounters all the time but doesn’t really understand, and that rarely makes its way into fiction.

Advertise with us

Reading it, I kept thinking how odd it is that so few contemporary novels have as their theme the structure of the modern economy, including the decline of brick-and-mortar retailing and the corrosive effects of the just-in-time scheduling.

Part of the reason, surely, is that it’s hard to make such stories entertaining. I doubt there are many authors who could write a literary critique of neoliberalism as breezy and almost sitcomlike as “Help Wanted.”

There’s also the fact that the publishing industry is dominated by the sort of expensively educated people who populated Waldman’s first book, and both editors and readers naturally gravitate toward narratives they can relate to.

But there’s a third reason that novels grappling with big questions of political economy have become relatively rare: the widespread worry that writing outside one’s own experience will be met with condemnation.

“Help Wanted” is a polyphonic novel whose point of view shifts among various workers on a team whose diversity, as a manager thinks to himself, “would have filled the headmaster of an elite private school with envy.” The characters include a middle-aged Black woman with an incarcerated son, a gay former teenage runaway with a wife and baby, and a Honduran immigrant supporting his bipolar girlfriend.

Advertise with us

In 2020 came the backlash against “American Dirt,” a book by a white woman — though one with a Puerto Rican grandmother — about Mexican migrants fleeing cartel violence that was lambasted for being exploitative and full of stereotypes.

Critics of “American Dirt” were generally careful to say that the problem was not that its author had ventured beyond her own identity but that she’d done it badly. In publishing, there was a widespread sense — intensifying after that summer’s racial justice protests — that writers who attempt to inhabit the perspectives of the less privileged risked ruinous accusations of cultural appropriation.

Non-workers writing

It doesn’t seem like a coincidence that, amid this growing anxiety about authenticity, there was a boom in autofiction, or fiction rooted in autobiography, and a decline in more panoramic novels about American life.

“The gatekeeping in fiction, as you know, is the MFA program,” novelist Gary Shteyngart, a friend of Waldman’s who teaches in the Master of Fine Arts program at Columbia University, told me.

Advertise with us

“Most of my students are in their 20s. Maybe some of them have had some kind of job here or there. But for the most part, there’s a lot of people who haven’t had a kind of traditional work life. So their first book can be somewhat autobiographical, right? And then they become a part of the academic publishing complex. And that’s what they write about.”

Waldman’s book is “a book about labor,” he said. “It’s about money in our society and what our society does to its lower-middle- and low-class rungs.”

So far, there hasn’t been much visible outrage. After a splashy profile of Waldman in New York magazine, I noticed a few snarky comments online, but they seemed to get little traction. Reader reviews on Goodreads, which can be vicious, are mostly positive.

I think you can attribute the lack of controversy, at least so far, to two things. Social media has become so fragmented — and X so right wing — that it’s harder for bad-faith actors to build clout by joining social justice pile-ons. There’s been a broader cultural turn against what’s often seen as left-wing stridency.

And, hopefully most significantly, Waldman writes about people radically unlike herself skillfully and without condescension. When she talks about her book, she tries to avoid sounding “grandiose” for “doing a job for six months that millions of people do year in and year out.”

Advertise with us

Turning outward

Maybe the book’s early reception is a sign that authors have more latitude to explore all strata of society than many have feared. In recent years, for reasons of both caution and fashion, many American writers have been looking inward.

But there’s a whole big world out there, and we need novelists to help us make sense of why it’s collapsing.

Michelle Goldberg is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article first appeared. Her previous article was “America must challenge Israel's extremists.”

Correction: This column was originally attributed to New York Times columnist Pamela Paul, not Ms. Goldberg. We apologize for the error.