The 34-count felony case against Donald Trump brought by the New York District Attorney Alvin Bragg has been widely disparaged, even by some liberals, as only about “money to hide an affair” and a weak case involving an alleged federal crime with weak facts tried in a state court. What is being overlooked is what Justice Department prosecutors — when Trump was president — publicly documented as the seriousness of the case.
It can be found in the Dec. 7, 2018, “Sentencing Memorandum” publicly filed by DOJ’s prosecutors in the prestigious Southern District of New York (the “SDNY”). I was one of the attorneys advising the defendant at the time, Michael Cohen, Donald Trump’s longtime attorney and fixer. (I am no longer representing Cohen for the trial.)
Four assertions
These prosecutors made four public assertions in this public document that undermine the conventional wisdom that this case is only about sex and that the factual basis to convict Donald Trump is weak:
The case involves issues that undermine “core” values of our democracy. The SDNY prosecutors wrote that Trump’s complicity in paying money to block disclosure of his extra-marital affairs on the eve of the 2016 presidential election struck “a blow at a core value essential to democracy: transparency.” Allowing such crimes would show that “the political process belongs to the rich and powerful.”
DOJ prosecutors in effect state that Mr. Trump was criminally responsible. The federal prosecutors wrote that Trump “directed” Michael Cohen to make the hush money payments a few days before the election for political reasons. This, they found, made Cohen complicit in the crime of knowingly violating federal campaign finance laws.
They noted that Cohen “admitted” to their factual finding. If Cohen was guilty of a crime to conceal relevant information from American voters before a crucial presidential election, then certainly Trump is just as guilty since he “directed” him to do it, according to Trump’s own prosecutors. These prosecutors found there was a political motivation to making these hush money payments, making it an illegal campaign donation.
Other witnesses
Bragg’s case does not depend solely on Michael Cohen’s testimony. Cohen has been found to be a credible witness — most recently, explicitly by New York Supreme Court Justice Arthur Engeron — but we know from the prosecutors that there were at least two witnesses other than Michael Cohen who could have testified in the federal case as to Trump’s knowledge and involvement in the illegal hush money scheme.
One was the chairman and CEO of a national tabloid magazine, whom the federal prosecutors stated Trump himself met with to discuss the scheme to kill negative stories. The second witness is said by the prosecutors to be the magazine’s editor-in-chief, whom these prosecutors aver was aware of and involved in the scheme.
Trump’s checks of $35,000 per month written from his personal checking account were not “legal fees” as he claimed. It was Justice Department lawyers working under Trump-appointed Attorney General William Barr, not locally elected Democratic prosecutors, who characterized these payments as illegal “reimbursements.” There it is, on page 14 sentencing memo that these checks were “falsely” recorded as business expenses on the books of the Trump Organization.
Trump himself recognized the potential legal danger of this SDNY sentencing memo as reflecting on his potential criminal guilt. He tried to expunge or “scrub” these incriminating words written by his own DOJ prosecutors. Attorney General Barr and others at DOJ reportedly pressured the SDNY prosecutors to delete these words and to “reverse” Michael Cohen’s guilty plea – this after Cohen served his time. Obviously, these efforts were not because Trump or Barr sympathized with Cohen’s plight.
The bottom line here is that that New York-based federal prosecutors made a determination that Trump and Cohen had violated federal campaign law. Trump was not charged federally with that crime, however, meaning that Alvin Bragg’s challenge is two-fold.
The prosecutor’s job
First, he must establish that New York state laws regulating financial fraud were violated when Trump was involved in illegal federal campaign donations. And second, he must show that when Trump falsely booked those hush money payments as “legal expenses” — which would normally be a misdemeanor in New York state law — he did so with the motive of concealing the other campaign finance crime under NY state law.
If Bragg can do so, then the 34 entries that were “falsely” listed as “legal expenses,” instead of being 34 misdemeanors, become 34 felonies. That could be a lot of jail time if that is the jury’s verdict. And lest we forget: Trump cannot pardon himself for state crimes if he wins the presidency.
The ultimate irony is that if Trump is found guilty of the New York state crimes, it will be his own Justice Department prosecutors who provided clear factual findings establishing his guilt.
Lanny Davis is the founder of the Washington, D.C., law firm, Lanny J. Davis & Associates.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.