Indi­vid­u­ally, we adore and pam­per our chil­dren. We shut­tle them from soc­cer prac­tice to mu­sic les­sons and then or­ga­nize their play dates with me­tic­u­lous fa­nat­i­cism. Yet col­lec­tively, we mis­treat Amer­ica’s chil­dren, es­pe­cially by the stan­dards of other wealthy coun­tries.

When we’re for­mu­lat­ing pol­i­cies for chil­dren as a whole rather than cod­dling our own lit­tle an­gels, we fall scan­dal­ously short. We prize chil­dren in the ab­stract but as a so­ci­ety tend to ig­nore their needs.

Chil­dren are more likely to go hun­gry or live in pov­erty in Amer­ica than in most of our peer coun­tries, and they are also much more likely to die — be­cause of drugs, guns, ac­ci­dents and an in­eq­ui­ta­ble health care sys­tem.

Too many left be­hind

If the United States sim­ply had the same mor­tal­ity rates for young peo­ple as the rest of the rich world, we would an­nu­ally save the lives of at least 40,000 Amer­i­cans age 19 and younger, ac­cord­ing to Steven Woolf, a pop­u­la­tion health ex­pert at Vir­ginia Com­mon­wealth Univer­sity. In other words, an Amer­i­can child dies about ev­ery 13 min­utes be­cause we don’t do as good a job as our peers in pro­tect­ing kids.

Advertise with us

And it’s get­ting worse. An Amer­i­can child’s chances of reach­ing adult­hood have fallen in re­cent years, Woolf told me.

This elec­tion year, these are is­sues that should be cen­tral in the bat­tles be­tween Dem­o­crats and Re­pub­li­cans. They’re not, for chil­dren don’t vote and are po­lit­i­cal or­phans.

The con­se­quences are felt not just by low-in­come chil­dren at the mar­gins. A coun­try as a whole can’t thrive when so many are left be­hind.

What dis­tin­guished the United States for more than a cen­tury and helped it be­come the world’s lead­ing econ­omy was strong mass ed­u­ca­tion that in­cluded wide­spread high school and col­lege at­ten­dance, even as some Euro­pean coun­tries did bet­ter with elite ed­u­ca­tion. But over the past 50 years we’ve fal­tered in sup­port­ing and ed­u­cat­ing chil­dren over­all as other coun­tries have moved ahead.

We’ve tried to fix prob­lems at the back end, with the ju­ve­nile justice sys­tem or crim­i­nal justice sys­tem, or with those alerts to look out for hu­man traf­fick­ers.

Advertise with us

But we have en­tire failed struc­tures, such as fos­ter care. Fewer than 5% of young peo­ple who’ve spent time in fos­ter care grad­u­ate from a four-year col­lege. Sev­eral stud­ies sug­gest that up to 60% of traf­fick­ing sur­vi­vors have been in the sys­tem. Yet when was the last time a pol­i­ti­cian was asked how to fix fos­ter care?

I’ve been think­ing about this be­cause I re­cently par­tic­i­pated in the Sum­mit on Amer­ica’s Kids and Fam­i­lies hosted by Com­mon Sense Me­dia. James St­eyer, the group’s founder, wants to push chil­dren onto the lo­cal, state and na­tional agenda so that po­lit­i­cal can­di­dates are forced to an­swer ques­tions about the well-be­ing of chil­dren.

Four sug­ges­tions

In the clos­ing ses­sion at the sum­mit, a few of us talked about what a pro-child agenda might look like. Here are my four sug­ges­tions:

An early child care pro­gram mod­eled af­ter the one that ex­ists in the U.S. mil­i­tary. If our armed forces can op­er­ate a child care pro­gram with fees based on abil­ity to pay, then the rest of the coun­try can as well.

Roughly one child in six is liv­ing with a par­ent who mis­used drugs in the past year, and some of these chil­dren can find a life­line in a high-qual­ity pro­gram such as Ed­u­care that also coaches par­ents. Other rich na­tions spend an av­er­age of about 29 times as much on child care per tod­dler as the United States.

Advertise with us

An ex­panded re­fund­able child tax credit. Most other wealthy coun­tries have in­tro­duced a monthly child al­low­ance to lift chil­dren out of pov­erty, and the United States fol­lowed in 2021 with the re­fund­able child tax credit. This huge suc­cess helped slash child pov­erty al­most in half. And then Re­pub­li­can op­po­si­tion caused the pro­gram to ex­pire at the end of 2021, and child pov­erty has soared again. This, at least, is a proposal that has bipartisan support.

A new reg­u­la­tory body to over­see tech­nol­ogy com­pa­nies and new me­dia. This would work the way the Fed­eral Com­mu­ni­ca­tions Com­mis­sion over­sees old me­dia. This idea has be­come ur­gent as TikTok and ar­ti­fi­cial in­tel­li­gence play a grow­ing pres­ence in chil­dren’s lives. Young peo­ple al­ready face a cri­sis in men­tal health that ap­pears cor­related to the spread of smart­phones and so­cial me­dia. I don’t want to over­regu­late, but tech com­pa­nies need over­sight as they mon­e­tize our chil­dren.

Im­prove­ments in K-14 ed­u­ca­tion to get ev­ery child lit­er­ate and nu­mer­ate. And grad­u­at­ing from high school and, where pos­si­ble, into at least com­mu­nity col­lege, the mil­i­tary or tech­ni­cal train­ing. Amer­i­can chil­dren are par­tic­u­larly in­com­pe­tent at math in ways that hold our en­tire coun­try back. If even Mis­sis­sippi, with un­con­scio­na­ble child pov­erty, can fo­cus on read­ing and sig­nifi­cantly raise ed­u­ca­tional out­comes, no state has an ex­cuse for let­ting stu­dents fail.

They’re our fu­ture

The best met­ric for a so­ci­ety’s fu­ture is how well it nur­tures its next gen­er­a­tion. This elec­tion year, let’s look be­yond the po­lit­i­cal horse race and cul­ture war to grill can­di­dates on their pol­i­cies to­ward chil­dren — and thus our coun­try’s fu­ture.

Nicholas Kristof is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article originally appeared. His previous article was “Does North Korea want war?”.