After grad­u­at­ing from high school in Ver­nal, Utah, Kray Has­lem spent seven years gain­ing the li­censes and ex­pe­ri­ence he needed to be­come a com­mer­cial air­line pi­lot. In 2019, he was work­ing as a flight in­struc­tor to gain flight hours and ad­vance his ca­reer.

One day, he was on a prac­tice flight with a stu­dent when shortly af­ter take­off, the en­gine failed and the plane crashed.

How work­ers can stay work­ing

Thank­fully, both Kray and his stu­dent sur­vived. But Kray’s in­ju­ries made it im­pos­sible for him to con­tinue his avi­a­tion ca­reer. In one mo­ment, the years of ef­fort he had in­vested in his ca­reer were use­less.

Advertise with us

As he re­cov­ered, he started look­ing for a new ca­reer to sup­port his fam­ily. He de­cided to com­plete a pro­gram­ming ap­pren­tice­ship and even­tu­ally be­gan work­ing as a back-end web de­vel­oper.

Tragic cir­cum­stances like Kray’s aren’t the only rea­son peo­ple are forced to switch ca­reers. To­day, ad­vances in ar­ti­fi­cial in­tel­li­gence are lead­ing many to won­der how work­ers will stay com­pet­i­tive. Re­search by Gold­man Sachs es­ti­mates that as many as two-thirds of jobs in the U.S. and Europe could be at least par­tially au­to­mated by AI in the fu­ture.

This chal­lenge isn’t new. Through­out his­tory, tech­no­log­i­cal ad­vances have pushed work­ers to gain new skills or move into new in­dus­tries to re­main rel­e­vant. For ex­am­ple, from 2000 to 2010, 5.6 mil­lion U.S. man­u­fac­tur­ing jobs were lost. Re­search­ers at Ball State Univer­sity es­ti­mated that 87.8% of those losses were caused by pro­duc­tiv­ity im­prove­ments, largely driven by tech­no­log­i­cal de­vel­op­ment.

As the pace of in­no­va­tion con­tin­ues to in­crease, how can we help dis­placed work­ers be­come qual­i­fied for work in new in­dus­tries? This pro­cess is known as re­skill­ing. Our re­search found that the most ef­fec­tive pro­grams have in­dus­try-driven cur­ric­u­lums, of­ten bol­stered by high lev­els of em­ployer in­volve­ment.

They also pro­vide trans­par­ent em­ploy­ment out­comes and widely rec­og­nized skill sig­nals, such as cre­den­tials. Ap­pren­tice­ships like the pro­gram Kray par­tic­i­pated in are strongly suited to pro­vide these.

Advertise with us

Trained on the job

In an ap­pren­tice­ship, stu­dents are trained on the job, typ­i­cally with sup­ple­men­tal class­room in­struc­tion. They learn the trade by do­ing the trade, learn­ing to han­dle the un­an­tic­i­pated chal­lenges and unique cus­tomer re­quests that arise in any real job.

For ex­am­ple, af­ter Kray de­vel­oped an un­der­stand­ing of the pro­gram­ming lan­guages his com­pany used, he so­lid­i­fied his skill set and built a port­fo­lio of ex­pe­ri­ence as he was put to work on real proj­ects for cli­ents.

Another ex­am­ple is elec­tri­cians, who ac­counted for the larg­est share of Amer­i­can ap­pren­tices in 2021. Ap­pren­tices in this field take classes on elec­tri­cal the­ory and reg­u­la­tion all while com­plet­ing some of the sev­eral thou­sand work hours needed for cer­ti­fi­ca­tion. This on-the-job ex­pe­ri­ence is su­per­vised by an ex­pe­ri­enced elec­tri­cian.

Em­ploy­ers face a di­rect in­cen­tive to give their train­ees the high­est-qual­ity train­ing pos­si­ble. A highly skilled ap­pren­tice is bet­ter equipped to cre­ate more value for their com­pany.

Advertise with us

Our re­search finds that this train­ing ap­proach is a pow­er­ful one. In one study, ap­pren­tices saw wage growth that was 2.7 times faster than that of sim­i­lar work­ers with­out the same hands-on train­ing. Ninety per­cent of reg­is­tered ap­pren­tices keep their jobs when they fin­ish train­ing.

Although ap­pren­tice­ships are com­mon in many coun­tries, they are rel­a­tively un­com­mon in the U.S. This is de­spite hun­dreds of mil­lions of dol­lars in fed­eral funds be­ing spent over the past few de­cades to sup­port their de­vel­op­ment.

Why aren’t ap­pren­tice­ships more com­mon? In many states, work­ers in spe­cific in­dus­tries must hold an oc­cu­pa­tional li­cense be­fore they are al­lowed to work, mak­ing it im­pos­sible for ap­pren­tices to learn on the job.

Some states have rec­og­nized this bar­rier. In Utah and Min­ne­sota, law­mak­ers have re­cently al­lowed for nurs­ing ap­pren­tice­ships in com­bi­na­tion with a tra­di­tional nurs­ing pro­gram. These changes are cru­cial to en­cour­age more work­ers to move into in-de­mand fields like health care.

In­cen­tiviz­ing busi­ness

Advertise with us

Another rea­son ap­pren­tice­ships aren’t more com­mon is that busi­nesses aren’t re­warded for pro­vid­ing them. Cur­rently, em­ploy­ers can’t de­duct the cost of in­vest­ing in hu­man cap­i­tal like they can for phys­i­cal as­sets like equip­ment.

One way to ex­pand ap­pren­tice­ships would be through a sim­ple change to the tax code. La­bor econ­o­mist Mi­chael Far­ren sug­gests al­low­ing busi­nesses to de­duct from their taxes the cost of re­skill­ing their em­ploy­ees.

This would in­cen­tivize more em­ploy­ers to start their own train­ing pro­grams, in­clud­ing in in­dus­tries where on-the-job train­ing is not cur­rently a com­mon prac­tice. These pro­grams could also ad­dress la­bor short­ages in fields like nurs­ing, IT and au­to­mo­tive work.

En­cour­ag­ing ap­pren­tice­ships would en­able more job seek­ers like Kray to ben­e­fit from paid, em­ployer-led ca­reer train­ing. In an era of sig­nifi­cant eco­nomic and tech­no­log­i­cal change, ef­fec­tive re­skill­ing pro­grams can be life-chang­ing for in­di­vid­u­als and can help main­tain a dy­namic work­force that ef­fec­tively em­braces new tech­nol­ogy.

Bren­den Bodily is an un­der­grad­u­ate re­search fel­low and Megan Jen­kins is se­nior re­search di­rec­tor at the Center for Growth and Op­por­tu­nity at Utah State Univer­sity.