National Transportation Safety Board investigation report reminds us that, much like liberty, our exceptional levels of commercial airline safety require eternal vigilance against the usual foes: greed, negligence, failure to adapt, complacency, revolving doors at regulatory agencies and so on.

But every report also reads like a how-to book for pulling off miracles and achieving seemingly incredible levels of safety. These reports renew one’s faith in what humanity can achieve if we apply our brainpower and resources.

Two miracles

On Jan. 2, a Japanese coast guard plane and an arriving Japan Airlines Airbus A350 collided. The Airbus turned into a fireball, yet all 379 people aboard got out safely. Last Friday, an Alaska Airlines Boeing 737 underwent rapid depressurization. The plane turned around and landed safely with no serious injuries reported.

Advertise with us

That everyone walked away from both crashes is a miracle — but not the kind most people think about. They’re miracles of regulation, training, expertise, effort, constant improvement of infrastructure, as well as professionalism and heroism.

These brave and determined men and women were standing on the shoulders of giants: competent bureaucrats; forensic investigators dispatched to accident investigations; large binders (nowadays digital) with hundreds and hundreds of pages of meticulously collected details of every aspect of accidents and near misses; constant training and retraining not just of the pilots but the cabin, ground, traffic control and maintenance crews; and a determined ethos that if something has gone wrong, the reason will be identified and fixed.

What happened after the Boeing 737 depressurization is textbook: The pilot declared an emergency, the air traffic control quickly arranged a clear runway, the plane circled right back and landed in just about 15 minutes.

It wasn’t all smooth sailing back to the airport. The cockpit door flew open from the depressurization, jamming against a bathroom door, and one pilot lost her headset. Still, you’d hardly know all that from listening to the communication between the pilots and the ground: just composed, competent professionalism on the way back to the gate.

Trained for emergencies

Advertise with us

The plane’s quick return to the airport, while much less dramatic, has similarities to the “Miracle on the Hudson” 15 years ago next Monday, when the now famed Captain Sully landed a plane on the Hudson River after losing its engines to a bird strike, saving everyone aboard. It’s what pilots train for, and it shows.

Listening to calm, collected communication between Capt. Chesley Sullenberger and the control tower during the four short minutes from the loss of all engine power to ditching in the Hudson, one might not realize the magnitude of what was about to happen: that he was about to attempt to land a cylindrical object weighing roughly 150,000 pounds in a narrow waterway next to one of the world’s largest cities.

But these kinds of emergencies are what pilots train for.

“One way of looking at this might be that, for 42 years, I’ve been making small regular deposits in this bank of experience: education and training,” he told Katie Couric shortly after the incident. “And on Jan. 15, the balance was sufficient so that I could make a very large withdrawal.”

The Boeing 737 Max line holds other lessons. After two eerily similar back-to-back crashes in 2018 and 2019, killing 346 people total, the planes were grounded. At first, some rushed to blame inexperienced pilots or software gone awry. But the world soon learned that the real problem had been corporate greed that had taken too many shortcuts while the regulators hadn’t managed to resist the onslaught.

Advertise with us

Even if the pilot is at fault, NTSB investigations are carried out as “no blame” processes — the goal is to identify the problem in order to make errors less likely in the future. This encourages people to be frank, in stark contrast with liability-driven cultures that encourage people to hide their errors and authorities to seek scapegoats rather than solutions.

Invisible infrastructure

As the facts come in, there will be more questions as to what went wrong. United Airlines and Alaska Airlines have both found loose bolts on the grounded Boeing airliners. Progress comes by acknowledging these failures and working to make them even less likely in the future.

Those NTSB investigation reports represent that kind of accumulation. Year by year, investigation by investigation, incident by incident, commercial flying has become remarkably safe despite the complexity of operation with so many moving parts at a global scale: humans, software, weather and metal objects flying through the sky.

Most of the time, it works so well that we don’t notice it — which is perhaps the true miracle of infrastructure that works well: It becomes invisible. Sometimes, it’s good to make visible the invisible many who keep us safe.

Advertise with us

Zeynep Tufekci, Craig Newmark Professor of Journalism at Columbia School of Journalism, is a columnist for the New York Times, where this article first appeared. His previous article was “The man who challenged those who thought the very poor shouldn't have good medical care.”