Dallas and Houston are two Democratic bubbles in Texas that have long faced the familiar urban ache of homeless people slumped on sidewalks and camping in parks. Both cities tried to address the challenge.

But smart policy matters far more than good intentions. In Dallas, homelessness worsened for years, and that city now has the most unhoused people in Texas. Meanwhile, the Houston region has slashed homelessness by more than 60% since 2011.

Homelessness is one of those topics that leaves Americans despairing, but Houston offers hope: It demonstrates what should be obvious, that a wealthy society doesn’t have to accept as inevitable throngs of people sleeping on sidewalks.

The city achieved its results on the cheap, spending very little of its own money even as cities like Los Angeles, San Francisco and Portland, Oregon, have each poured hundreds of millions of dollars into efforts to address homelessness without much to show for them. What unfolded wasn’t a triumph of compassion so much as one of evidence, management and impeccable execution.

Advertise with us

Houston’s secrets

So what is Houston’s secret? First, the city had strong political leaders who herded nonprofits so that they worked in unison rather than competing.

Second, Houston’s lack of regulation makes it easy, quick and cheap to build new apartments. Building a small one-bedroom can cost less than $200,000, while Los Angeles spent as much as $837,000 per apartment.

Third, Houston focused less on general help, such as handing out jackets or providing counseling, and more on moving people into apartments and providing ongoing care to keep them housed.

A pillar of the Houston approach is “housing first”: the idea that people should get housing even if they are abusing drugs or alcohol. The thinking behind this is that it may be easier for someone to overcome an addiction while safe in an apartment rather than cold on a wet sidewalk and feeling a need to self-medicate.

Advertise with us

In practice

To see what Houston’s approach looked like in practice, I shadowed Molly Permenter, an outreach worker, one morning. Permenter told me she had fled an abusive home at the age of about 16, slept under park benches, used drugs and was sex trafficked. She finally escaped and entered the Coast Guard, turned her life around and eventually joined Houston’s Coalition for the Homeless to try to help others in the position she had once been in.

Permenter understands the challenges. She guesses that if an outreach worker had ever approached her when she was on the street, she might have cursed that person.

After parking her car by a small wooded area near George Bush Intercontinental Airport, Permenter cautiously entered the forest along with a colleague from the coalition. We found an encampment hidden in the trees, home to 10 people whose unofficial leader was a charismatic 31-year-old named Joe Cavazos.

Lean and muscular, Cavazos said he was a construction worker until a shard of glass fell and cut his arm six months earlier, leaving him partly disabled. He lost his job, his car and his home, but he put his skills to use building shacks; one was a two-story marvel made of wood scraps.

Advertise with us

Clearly intelligent and industrious, Cavazos said he was expelled from high school in the 11th grade but later studied electronics at a trade school. He told me that while homeless he made a living fixing televisions and computers and reselling them. A neighboring business owner offered a different account, saying that some people in the encampment stole equipment to sell. While I was chatting with Cavazos, the business owner approached us. Cavazos angrily leaped to his feet, and for a moment I worried that they were close to a fistfight. But the business owner quickly retreated, seething.

Cavazos said he had once struggled with alcohol but had been sober for eight years. I asked about drugs and didn’t get a clear answer, but he did volunteer that he was off his mental health medication.

“It made me feel worse,” he said. I asked what his diagnosis was. “I got ADHD, bipolar personality disorder, schizo, that’s what they’re telling me,” he said. “I don’t know. I’m perfectly fine.”

Permenter asked Cavazos if he would like to get on a waitlist for housing. He said yes but didn’t know where to start. When he agreed to undergo an assessment, Permenter asked him a series of standardized questions.

Important innovation

Advertise with us

One of Houston’s most important innovations was to establish Coalition for the Homeless as an independent, outside agency to coordinate 100 nonprofits. In other cities, organizations are well meaning but scattered, so one homeless person may have contact with three nonprofits while another has contact with none — and none may be focused on getting a roof over someone’s head.

In Houston, people are mostly placed in apartments, not temporary shelters, and they receive case management to help with jobs, benefits, behavioral health and other needs. The system works well in getting people back on their feet but is not perfect. A year after finishing a program that provided a year’s rent in an apartment, 8% had returned to homelessness.

Outreach workers try to gauge whether people have a potential income source, such as disability or veterans benefits, and if so, offer help in applying for it. The assessment may involve trying to locate a relative who would be willing to offer a bedroom. They also help in getting homeless people the IDs they need to apply for benefits.

A homelessness myth

One myth that bedevils policymaking about homelessness: It is all about drugs, alcohol and mental illness. Addiction can complicate homelessness, but the principal driver is simply not enough housing. Consider that West Virginia has a huge addiction crisis yet doesn’t have much homelessness — because someone can rent a one-bedroom apartment there for less than $500 a month.

Advertise with us

High rates of homelessness don’t correlate with high levels of addiction, poverty or mental illness, but rather two related factors: high rents and low availability of rental housing.

So why is it that many who are homeless have mental health or addiction problems? It’s mostly because when there’s a shortage of housing, there’s a scramble — and the people with the lowest incomes and the least competence at managing the system are the ones left on the street.

The metaphor commonly applied is musical chairs. In a game of musical chairs, an elderly person may not be fast enough to grab a seat. The solution is simply to add a chair.

Another challenge is that it’s often difficult to persuade landlords to rent to people who need housing most desperately. Houston has overcome this resistance by appealing to landlords to help solve an urgent city problem — and by offering a $1,600 incentive fee per unit.

Housing may pay for itself

Advertise with us

Moving people from the streets into apartments may pay for itself. The coalition says that the cost in Houston of housing and supporting someone who would otherwise be homeless is about $20,000 a year (about $13,000 in housing and $7,000 in case management). The same individual on the streets could accumulate a far higher tab with a few ambulance trips, hospital stays and jailings (people who are homeless make up a disproportionate share of people arrested).

While homelessness is mostly driven by a lack of housing units, it’s of course more than that. Some of the people I interviewed in Houston were in such a haze, from mental illness or substance use, that they didn’t know where they were.

Housing trade-offs can be uncomfortable for liberals like me. We like zoning that protects our neighborhoods and prevents urban sprawl, but the downside is more expensive housing and higher rates of homelessness. I was forced to reassess how I weighed the trade-offs when a school friend, Stacy, froze to death while homeless in Oregon. I wondered: If we accepted more sprawl, would she have found cheap housing and survived?

There’s a serious conversation to have about whether we have made it too difficult to commit people involuntarily and get them help. Stacy was homeless because of mental illness and alcoholism, and it’s not obvious to me that we were respecting Stacy’s autonomy by letting her suffer and die.

Houston’s funding challenge

Advertise with us

Houston’s challenge ahead is that its success in recent years has come from shrewd use of federal COVID relief funds that are now running out. It’s not clear how the city will finance further rehousing. Advocates are talking about a bond issue or a special tax, but voters may not approve.

Thirty thousand Houstonians have been housed in the last dozen years. The lesson I take from Houston is that success doesn’t come from repeating bromides about housing as a human right. Houston has succeeded because it has strong political leadership that gathers data, follows evidence and herds nonprofits in the same direction.

Nicholas Kristof is a columnist for The New York Times, where this article originally appeared. His previous article was “We’re complicit in the horror in Gaza.”