For many for­eign­ers, the prev­a­lence of ath­let­ics is one of the strang­est fea­tures of the U.S. sys­tem of higher ed­u­ca­tion. Amer­ica is a leader in Nobel prizes, and its uni­ver­sities are home to many of the world’s great­est think­ers. At the same time, many U.S. col­leges are drenched in an ap­par­ently anti-in­tel­lec­tual prac­tice known as sports.

Many U.S. col­leges, in­clud­ing those at the high­est ac­a­demic lev­els, use sports per­for­mance as one cri­te­rion for ad­mis­sion. If you are a star quar­ter­back or a very good la­crosse player, you have a bet­ter chance of get­ting into a bet­ter school. This is not the case in most other ad­vanced coun­tries.

And yet: There is some­thing to be said for this in­ter­twin­ing of the life of the mind and the life of the body.

In­ter­twin­ing mind and body

Advertise with us

At the philo­soph­i­cal level, the man­age­ment and de­ploy­ment of the body is very much a cog­ni­tive ex­er­cise. Play­ing sports re­quires prob­lem-solv­ing and de­ci­sion-mak­ing un­der pres­sure. These feats are just as cog­ni­tively im­pres­sive as writ­ing a good term pa­per on 16th cen­tury Brit­ish Renais­sance po­etry.

Fur­ther­more, as ar­ti­fi­cial in­tel­li­gence con­tin­ues to ad­vance, an­other AI — ath­letic in­tel­li­gence — will in­creas­ingly be­come a uniquely hu­man trait. It is ap­pro­pri­ate for our sys­tems of higher ed­u­ca­tion to rec­og­nize and even cel­e­brate this. ChatGPT may be able to write a good es­say, but it can’t de­cide whether to dou­ble-team the player ad­vanc­ing with the ball.

More prag­mat­i­cally, col­lege sports is an ef­fec­tive way for many schools to raise money. It keeps alumni com­ing back to cam­pus, and top do­nors can be given perks such as nice seats or sea­son tick­ets. If a school is known for its foot­ball team, that can help it re­cruit stu­dents and per­haps fac­ulty.

As for the stu­dents them­selves, re­cent re­search in­di­cates that sports per­for­mance makes for­mer stu­dent ath­letes more valu­able in the work­place. Former col­lege ath­letes are much more likely to en­ter the high-earn­ing fields of busi­ness and fi­nance, rel­a­tive to their non-ath­lete class­mates. That can ben­e­fit the for­mer stu­dents, their alma ma­ter and the over­all econ­omy.

The re­search also shows that stu­dent ath­letes are less likely to get a doc­toral de­gree or be­come a med­i­cal doc­tor, or to en­ter STEM fields. Might it be that the STEM jobs will be­come the prov­ince of the less ath­letic?

Advertise with us

Ath­letes do bet­ter

Look­ing at just Ivy League grad­u­ates, for­mer ath­letes do bet­ter in the la­bor mar­ket — that is, they earn more money — than non-ath­letes. This re­sult holds even when con­trolled for school at­tended, year of grad­u­a­tion, field of study and first job.

Those same ath­letes are also more likely to hold se­nior po­si­tions. That could be ev­i­dence of lead­er­ship skills, or of their abil­ity to learn and im­prove over time, as in­deed good ath­letes must do. After five years, the earn­ings of the for­mer col­lege ath­letes start to out­per­form their non-ath­letic peers.

It is hard to avoid the con­clu­sion that col­lege ath­letes ac­tu­ally learn some­thing use­ful. And what they learn, in many cases, is prob­a­bly lead­er­ship skills. It is also pos­si­ble that their ath­letic ex­pe­ri­ences sharpen their wits, their com­pet­i­tive sense, their prob­lem-solv­ing acu­men and their abil­ity to work with oth­ers.

In­ter­est­ingly, the same study shows that ath­letes in more so­cio­eco­nom­i­cally di­verse sports, such as track and field, also earn more than their non-ath­letic peers. This sug­gests that their ad­van­tage comes not from hav­ing at­tended some fancy prep school.

Advertise with us

All of a sud­den, the life of the body and the life of the mind do not seem so dis­tinct.

Beyond the class­room

This is an age of ris­ing skep­ti­cism about higher ed­u­ca­tion, much of it jus­ti­fi­able. Maybe peo­ple would be less cyn­i­cal about higher ed­u­ca­tion if it ex­panded its fo­cus be­yond the class­room.

It can and should in­clude vo­ca­tional school, hands-on proj­ects such as man­ag­ing an AI or, in­deed, suit­ing up for a bas­ket­ball game. If sports help boost stu­dents’ earn­ing po­ten­tial and lead­er­ship skills, other forms of hands-on ex­pe­ri­ence will probaby have the same ef­fect.

Of course if you see Amer­i­can so­ci­ety as too com­pet­i­tive, or too ob­sessed with earn­ings, you still might find grounds to ob­ject to col­le­giate sports. But I am in­creas­ingly of the opin­ion that col­lege ath­let­ics help Amer­ica re­al­ize its true po­ten­tial.

Tyler Cowen, a columnist for Bloomberg Opinion, is professor of economics at George Mason University. His previous article was “The problem with misinformation: People want it.”