I intended to write a normal horse-race column this week, about what we can glean from the polling that came out after the first Republican debate. But is anything we could learn from one Republican debate more significant than the news that the most important legal case against Trump, his federal trial for alleged election-related crimes, will begin the day before Super Tuesday?
Probably not.
Trial and campaign intertwined
If you take the judicial process seriously — as an exercise in fact finding and adversarial argument, with the presumption of innocence at the outset yielding to a legitimate verdict at the end — then clearly the trial of a major presidential contender should be completed before voters begin passing judgments of their own. Under less optimal circumstances, a verdict would be rendered before most of the votes are cast, so that a majority of the electorate knew the decision.
To its credit, that’s what the prosecution asked for: a January start date, with the trial potentially wrapping up around the end of the first phase of the campaign. But instead we’re headed for a world where the trial and the campaign are fully intertwined, with some votes cast pretrial, some after the opening statements, some with the prosecution’s arguments as a backdrop, and some following the defense’s rebuttal.
This affects these trials as an attempted vindication of the rule of the law. Everyone watching can see that the law’s decisions are provisional and the final arbiter of Trump’s fate is the voting public. The Republican primary electorate will be a kind of shadow jury, offering its reactions in real time, constantly raising or lowering the odds that the defendant can reverse a guilty verdict by the simple expedient of becoming the next president of the United States.
Read More
The shrugging response from many liberals is that there’s simply no alternative here. Trump committed so many potential crimes that the pileup of cases requires at least one, and possibly several, to go to trial during the primary campaign.
A boon for Trump
New York and Georgia prosecutors didn’t get together with Merrick Garland and Jack Smith and plan things to end this way, and some of the federal delay arguably reflected a reluctance to pursue a case. But there is still a recurring pattern with these anti-Trump, anti-populist efforts, which so often seem to converge on stratagems and choices that further undermine confidence in officially neutral institutions.
These choices are often defended with the suggestion that any criticism is just a bad-faith attempt to let Trump or his voters off the hook. So in that vein it should be stressed that Trump’s voters are responsible for his continued popularity, that he might well be headed to renomination without the pileup of prosecutions and that prosecutors aren’t forcing GOP voters to do anything they don’t seem inclined to do already.
But the pileup still seems like a boon to his renomination effort. Yes, there’s always “the possibility that Trump collapses under the weight of his legal challenges,” as my New York Times colleague Nate Cohn puts it. But we have months of polling in the shadow of these prosecutions.
It strongly suggests that the core Trump bloc (30% to 40% of the Republican electorate, let’s say) will vote for him no matter what. And another bloc is open to alternatives but rallies to him when he’s perceived to be liberalism’s major target, in much the same spirit that liberals and feminists once rallied to an accused sexual predator named Bill Clinton when he was the target of the religious right.
To beat Trump in the primaries, challengers would need part of that bloc to resist the rallying impulse and swing their way instead. So timing Trump’s prosecution but not the final outcome of the trial to some of the most important primaries seems more likely to cement his nomination than to finally make his poll numbers collapse.
A conviction might stop him
A conviction might be a different matter. There may be Republican voters who regard these prosecutions as theater designed to keep Trump from the nomination and therefore expect the legal cases to fall apart when his lawyers make their defense.
But a Reuters/Ipsos poll a few weeks ago found that 45% of the GOP electorate said they wouldn’t vote for Trump if he was convicted of a felony. A smaller group of 35% (that Trumpian core again) said they would. More than half said they wouldn’t support him in the fall campaign if he was imprisoned.
I do not believe the latter number, but at the very least the poll suggests that there is still enough faith in the legal system for an actual conviction to have a different effect on the Republican primary than the prosecutions have thus far.
But on the current timeline, a conviction before the primary is decided is exactly what we aren’t going to get.
Ross Douthat is a columnist for The New York Times, where his article originally appeared. His previous article was “‘Oppenheimer' goes too easy on Stalin.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.