In 2018, Californians voted on a state law that would, in part, ban the sale of pork meat in California unless the meat was produced in compliance with the law’s more humane rules for housing breeding sows. The state’s pork industry took the matter to court, claiming the law violated the Constitution’s commerce clause, because it affected out of state producers and consumers, not just Californians.
The legal challenges to the law have so far have been dismissed, first by the district court, and then by the 9th circuit court. Now the case has reached the United States Supreme Court. The case, National Pork Producers Council v. Ross, was heard last October. The court will give its decision this spring.
Was this law really necessary? Should states like our own pass the same law?
Yes and yes. Certainly, a majority of the voters of California think so. The gestation crates where these animals are kept are cramped — so cramped, in fact, that the mother pigs can barely move at all. The conditions become filthy, and the pigs suffer psychological and physical harm. This way of raising pigs is inhumane.
Most of us would cringe to see similarly intelligent animals, like our well-loved dogs and cats, treated in such a way. Pigs’ intelligence is well-documented. They love to play, form social relationships, connect with people, can solve problems, and are capable of complex learning. In fact, many countries and even 10 U.S. states have either already banned or will soon ban gestation crates because they are inhumane.
Pigs like Baba Yaga, pictured above. She and her “boyfriend” were going to be sent to slaughter once the owner decided not to breed them. Someone convinced the owner to surrender her to Pittsburgh Squealers Rescue instead. At the rescue, she is thriving, living as a pig should, playing with other pigs, stretching her legs, and breathing fresh air.
Read More
As it turns out, you don’t have to care about the welfare of these creatures to agree with Californians’ decision to pass Proposition 12. In 2019 and 2020, many recognized the wet markets in China as a potential breeding-ground for zoonotic diseases which could cross over to humans, because animals were kept in cramped and dirty cages. Pigs’ gestation crates are no better.
Mother pigs are trapped laying in the same straw, unable to stand or move to go to the bathroom or even roll over to avoid sores. The conditions weaken bow the sows’ and the piglet’s immune systems, increasing the possibility of their developing zoonotic diseases. These pathogens may not be detected and the meat go out for sale to unknowing consumers.
And the dangers of diseases are exponentially greater for the people working in these conditions. Cleaning these areas — when it does happen — exposes agricultural workers to all of the bacteria, not to mention viruses, that thrive in those close, unclean spaces. It is bad for them and for those with whom they come in contact.
Some may look at the name of this case, seeing “National Pork Producers Council, et al,” and wonder if this law places undue burdens on pig farmers or others who raise livestock — especially those here in Pa. who may want to sell pork out of state.
The answer turns out to be no. Two agricultural and resource economics professors at UC Davis explained in their brief to SCOTUS that the pork producers’ main economic argument is “erroneous and implausible,” because the law “does not require any pork producer to comply with its provisions.” Pennsylvania’s farmers appear to be off the hook, legally speaking.
But while we’re on the topic, many private companies have already made pledges not to sell gestation-crate-produced pork and to require gestation-crate-free pork from their pork suppliers. There is a consumer mandate — understandably so, when weighing both the ethical and health considerations — for producers to treat pigs more humanely. That mandate insures that producers who practice humane farming will economically viable.
If you are as charmed by Baba Yaga as our friends at the Pittsburgh Squealers Rescue were; if you care about the clean working conditions of those who work with these animals; if you want to avoid a pandemic starting with a zoonotic disease; if you just want to know the meat you’re eating came from a pig raised in clean and safe conditions; or even if you just believe that California voters have the right to decide what conditions are acceptable for the meat that is sold in their grocery stores; I hope you’ll join me as we watch for the SCOTUS decision — and if the law is upheld, urge our own state legislature to pass our own Proposition 12.
Natalie Ahwesh is the executive director of Humane Action Pittsburgh and director of state affairs for Animal Wellness Action. Her previous article was “We don’t need to experiment on animals.” Hannah Lewis, grant writer for HAP, and Kate Schultz, senior attorney for Animal Wellness Action contributed to this article.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.