Young Americans need “a stiffening of the vertebrae,” according to prominent businessman Elbert Hubbard. He laments their “foolish inattention” and “dowdy indifference,” but he finds a silver lining: socialism will have no chance with the young, because if our youth “won’t act for themselves, what will they do when the benefit of their effort is for all?”
Of course the punch line to all this is that Hubbard wrote what he did in 1899. Let’s say up front that a downcast view of young people in the U.S. is arguably as old as the United States.
Writing about 1920s America in his 1931 book “Only Yesterday,” historian Frederick Lewis Allen recalled how “Fathers and mothers lay awake asking themselves whether their children were not utterly lost.” University of Florida president Albert Murphree certainly felt they were. In his estimation, America’s females with their “low-cut gowns” and short skirts were “carrying the present and future generations to chaos and destruction.”
In the 1970s, philosopher Eric Hoffer observed about America’s young that they “are not willing to do the hard work by which alone the world can be improved.” Worse, “one has the impression that [the] young do not want to, or perhaps cannot, grow up.” In the 1990s it was Generation X’s turn. In the words of “X” chronicler Douglas Coupland (“Generation X: Tales for an Accelerated Culture”), his youthful subjects with impressive educational backgrounds had graduated into “low-pay, low-prestige, low-benefit, no-future jobs in the service industry.”
It seems the desire to downplay the prospects (and frequently talents) of the luckiest people on earth — yes, that would be young American people — is too enticing for the pundit class. Writing of the Millennials in the Washington Post in 2011, the late Robert Samuelson observed that “A specter haunts America: downward mobility. Every generation, we believe, should live better than its predecessors,” but “[f]or young Americans, the future could be dimmer.” National Review’s Kevin Williamson confidently asserted that a generation prone to communicating with “smiley faces and 140-character bursts of text” was quite simply “hosed.”
Fast forward to the present. As predicted in my 2018 book “The End of Work,” the Millennials formerly expected to live in the proverbial parental basement evolved into the richest generation in the history of the richest nation on earth.
Read More
Now, academic Jonathan Haidt has discovered Generation Z. According to the NYU professor, “We have a whole generation that’s doing terribly.” History says he will be as stupendously incorrect as the myriad pessimists who came before him.
In a recent interview, Haidt asserted that there’s “never been a generation this depressed, anxious and fragile.” He attributes the weakness of young America to a combination of social media and a culture that sees victims everywhere. The introduction of the iPhone 4 in 2010 (with its front facing camera) combined with Facebook’s acquisition of Instagram in 2012 led to “a major depression,” particularly among girls.
“You post your perfect life, and then you flip through the photos of other girls who have a more perfect life, and you feel depressed.” Oh yes, before the 2010s, looks didn’t matter, there were no Sports Illustrated swimsuit issues, no catalogues, no pin-up models, no beauty queens, no bulimia, etc.
Haidt is of the view that young people “no longer even hang out together” because they have no social or physical desires. Realistically, posting on social media is evidence of an active life with others, and an instigator of even more human interaction.
And there’s a problem with the economics of his dark view of the future. Trite as it may sound, young people are the future. Markets are a look into the future, and if social media were destroying the future, the market now would be bleak. If the social media companies had caused a generation to perform “terribly,” they would not have reached trillion dollar valuations.
Haidt claims that by 2015 the wrecking of Gen Z was “an epidemic.” Yet the value of the corporations that were allegedly ruining the future had their best years ahead of them. Better yet, their valuations proved a lure for investment capital meant to replace the present. See TikTok, among others.
The professor has a solution to his imaginary crisis. More rules, less freedom. Government should “raise the age of Internet adulthood to 16, and enforce it.” Yes, take away freedom in order to protect a “fragile” generation from itself. Oh dear.
Haidt’s interview won’t age well. He’s the latest in a long line of deep thinkers to predict an ugly future for America’s youth. And he won’t be the last incredibly serious person to lament “kids these days.”
John Tamny is editor of RealClearMarkets. His previous article was “How inequality serves the poor. With air conditioning, for example.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.