Gina Raimondo doesn't “know why any woman would want to live in a state that criminalizes full access to health care.” The assertion by the 40th U.S. Secretary of Commerce is especially relevant with so many abortion clinics closing after Dobbs, mostly in the South and Midwest.
“Healthy workers are more productive,” she said during a Zoom interview. “They show up every day, on time, ready to work — so I think states that provide better access to health care enable a more productive workforce.”
Raimondo is the former venture capitalist and first woman elected and re-elected governor of her native state of Rhode Island. She mended a pension system on the brink of collapse, fixed a crumbling transportation infrastructure, forgave student-loan debt, tripled the number of pre-kindergarten classes and guaranteed that every child can attend all-day kindergarten.
She recruited more than 30 companies to Rhode Island. Unemployment plummeted to 3.4%, or 3.1 percentage points below its 30-year average and almost half the rate when she took office in 2015.
“You have to do more than just deregulate and lower taxes to drive growth and attract business,” she said. “You also need high quality of life, high quality health care, high quality public schools, a well-trained workforce, and a place people want to live.”
Raimondo added another bulwark to her state's competitiveness when she signed into law the Reproductive Privacy Act in 2019, protecting abortion rights by anticipating the Supreme Court's repeal of Roe v. Wade.
Read More
She isn't “at all surprised” to see data showing publicly-traded companies in the 11 states where abortion is illegal — Alabama, Arkansas, Idaho, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas — are less diverse, less profitable and less productive than the U.S. average for big and small firms alike. They are inferior to companies in the 10 states that expanded access to abortion — Washington, Oregon, California, Minnesota, Illinois, New York, Vermont, Connecticut, New Jersey, Pennsylvania — since 2020, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
To be sure, there are many determinants beyond reproductive rights that explain why companies in some states outperform their peers in other states. “The best-performing companies are the ones who are able to attract, recruit, retain and develop the top talent,” Raimondo said. “That means men and women.” Women, especially, “are going to want to work in companies and in states where they can have full access to health care, including reproductive health care.”
The Supreme Court decision giving states the power to ban abortion is proving so unpopular that voters in Kansas, by an overwhelming margin (59%-41%), rejected a proposed constitutional amendment in August that would have removed the right to an abortion from the state’s constitution. Similar referendums were rejected on election day last month in Kentucky and Montana, as Americans across the nation turned out to vote for reproductive freedom.
The U.S. economy already is suffering the economic consequences in states that have criminalized abortion. In the 10 pro-choice states, since April 2020, as the COVID-19 labor market began its recovery from the worst recession since the Great Depression, non-farm payrolls increased an average 18.3%, compared with 16.9% for the country as a whole, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The 11 anti-abortion states lagged behind with 15.1% job growth.
Since the beginning of 2022, employment in the pro-choice states climbed 2.8%, exceeding the nation's 2.5% rate. That easily surpassed the 2.3% for the anti-abortion states.
The labor participation rate for women in the anti-abortion states criminalizing abortion is 56%, or 9.5 percentage points lower than it is for men, and below the 60% and 9.3 percentage points rates for the 10 pro-choice states.
Corporate America already shows diminished diversity in places where abortion is criminalized. The 500 publicly-traded companies with a stock market value of at least $200 million that are based in the 11 anti-abortion states have women among only 20% of their executives, 27% of their managers and 35% of their employees.
The 1,600 companies based in the pro-choice states have percentages of 24%, 31% and 41%. Companies in those states are also more diverse than the entire group of Russell 3000 Index firms, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
Companies based in those states outperformed the Russell 3000 and their peers in the 11 anti-abortion states. Earnings came in 1% greater than estimates on average during the past three years, while those where it is illegal saw results fall 74% below estimates on average. Earnings for members of the index overall came in 9% below estimates.
Firms in the pro-choice states also reported $183 million of profit per 1,000 employees during the past three years as Russell 3000 firms reported $155 million and companies in anti-abortion states made $91 million for the same amount of workers, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Productivity for firms in pro-choice states increased 485% compared with 380% for the Russell 3000 and proved superior to the 190% for firms in states where abortion is illegal.
“If I were still a governor, I would look at this data as a huge opportunity,” said Raimondo. “I'd be going to these states at the top of the [illegal abortion] list and actively recruit those companies to my state. If you look right now at inflation and what continues to drive inflation is this stubborn tight labor market, enable women to work at their full productivity level. If you have more labor in the labor force, inflation will be reduced. That's an economic fact.”
Matthew A. Winkler is editor in chief emeritus of Bloomberg News. He wrote with the assistance of Shin Pei and Daniella Goncalves.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.