We hear a great deal today from both parties about protecting democracy. According to Republicans, democracy needs to be protected from illegal voting, while Democrats decry election deniers. But the truth is, neither party gives a tinker’s damn about what the majority of the American people want. The only thing they are concerned about is what a majority of their primary voters want.
On issue after issue, polling shows that there is a broad consensus among Americans on most issues. Morris Fiorina, in his book “Unstable Majorities,” describes a survey that the American National Election Survey has been conducting since 1984.
The poll asked Americans’ opinions on five issues, giving the respondents seven multiple choices. The seven responses range from “one” (being the most liberal) to “seven” (being the most conservative). From 1984 to 2016, a plurality of 30 to 35% selected the “four” response, i.e., the most moderate position. Answers “three,” “four,” and “five” got combined responses over 70%.
Even on issues that are supposedly highly polarized, such as abortion, there is actually a consensus among Americans. When Americans are asked the question of whether they are pro-life or pro-choice, the country is pretty evenly divided. But when asked what they mean by that, a much more complex picture emerges, which reflects a general consensus.
An extensive survey done by the Pew Foundation probed how support for the right to an abortion was affected by various circumstances and how far into the term the pregnancy was. The results showed Americans’ views on abortion are much more nuanced than just the life-choice dichotomy.
To me, Pew’s survey shows most of Americans support the right to an abortion early in the pregnancy but that after about 12 to 15 weeks, a woman needs to have a good reason to terminate the pregnancy. Factors enjoying widespread support for an abortion later in the pregnancy include risk to the mother’s health, fetal deformity, and rape/incest.
Read More
I recently spoke at a breakfast and asked how many were pro-life and pro-choice. It was about 50 to 50. I then suggested we try to write an abortion law. I asked how many thought abortions should be illegal in all circumstances with no exceptions. No one raised their hand. I then asked how many thought there should be absolutely no restrictions on abortions. No one raised their hand.
I then took a vote on when abortion restrictions should kick in. About 12 to 15 weeks was supported by about two-thirds of the room. About the same percentage supported exceptions later than 12 to 15 weeks for the mother’s health, fetal deformity, and rape/incest.
So, a room that was, at first blush, polarized over abortion quickly found that a large majority agreed on the policy that should be enacted. And they also discovered that no one in the room supported the extreme positions currently reflected in the platforms of the Republican and Democratic parties.
The truth is that we have a political system that routinely frustrates the will of the American people. There are many reasons we have evolved into this anti-democratic paradigm. Certainly, the reliance on the primary system to nominate candidates combined with extreme partisan gerrymandering is the principal culprit. But also, the conspiring of the two dominant parties to restrict electoral competition plays a large part.
In my home state of Texas, for example, it costs over $1 million to get a new party or independent candidate on the ballot. And even if you have a spare million bucks, you still must jump through multiple hoops, such as requiring over 90,000 signatures in 75 days on notarized paper petitions.
Confoundingly, the courts have given the states a wide berth in allowing such blatant discrimination against third parties and independents under the guise of avoiding “ballot confusion” for voters. In other words, you are too stupid to make an informed decision if there are more than two or three choices on your ballot. Perhaps if the selection of judges was not partisan for the most part in our country, they would have a higher opinion of the intelligence of the American people.
But there is some reason for hope. Increasingly, in states that allow direct action by their citizens, ballot initiatives on electoral reforms are winning support. And recently, a federal court in Texas has ruled that requiring petitions to be collected on paper forms is unconstitutional.
But the change will be slow until the rational middle of America stands up and says it has had enough of the extremism and demands change.
Bill King, a businessman and lawyer, has served as a city councilman and is the author of “Saving Face” and “Unapologetically Moderate.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.