I was thrilled to have gotten a seat in the middle of the fifth row of the Chautauqua amphitheater that Friday morning. I came to see one of my literary heroes, Salman Rushdie, who was there to speak about the importance of providing persecuted writers with a place of asylum. Who better to speak on the subject than Mr. Rushdie, still living under an Iranian fatwa, with a multimillion-dollar bounty on his head? In light of Mr. Rushdie’s notoriety, my husband and I arrived earlier than usual, expecting a larger-than-normal crowd (there was) and possible delays for security procedures (there weren’t).
Our seats afforded us close-up views of Mr. Rushdie and Henry Reese, co-founder of the Pittsburgh chapter of the City of Asylum network, an international organization begun by Rushdie to offer safe haven to persecuted writers from around the world.
Just as the speakers were about to be introduced, a masked and hooded man rushed the stage and began attacking Mr. Rushdie. We watched, first in shock and then in horror, as the situation unfolded, with Mr. Rushdie being pummeled and stabbed repeatedly.
Thankfully, some brave spectators were able to make their way on stage and wrestle the attacker to the ground and hold him down. Only then did the first uniformed law enforcement official finally join them there, where Mr. Rushdie lay bleeding. My best estimate is that the attack lasted about 30 seconds — although it felt much longer.
Most of us in the audience stood in stunned silence. A Chautauqua official calmly asked audience members to evacuate the amphitheater. Being so close to the stage, our route took us past the side of the stage, where Mr. Rushdie was now being attended to by physicians from the audience who had rushed to his aid.
Outside in the bright light of the clear day, people sobbed and shook and hugged as we anxiously awaited news on whether Mr. Rushdie’s life could be saved.
I watched from a few yards away as the attacker, later identified by police as a 24-year-old man, was led out, handcuffed. He stood, both his body and gaze open to those of us who bore witness, as he was searched and his shoes were removed.
I had moved closer because I wanted to look him in the eye, to try to fathom how one human being could perpetrate such an act of barbarism upon another, a 75-year-old man no less.
The attacker met my gaze. In fact, he looked intently at the several of us closest to him, his face youthful and unlined, his gaze stark and defiant, challenging and seemingly unrepentant. I don’t know what I had expected to see in him, but I was unprepared for the rage I felt toward him.
Fighting words and ideas with fists and a knife is inequitable. The pen, as they say, is mightier than the sword. So surely it is mightier than the knife. For 30 years, with a fatwa on his head, Salman Rushdie has continued to write and to speak and to advocate for artistic and personal freedom, in opposition to those who placed a bounty on his head to silence him. And on Friday morning, one young attacker attempted to do just that.
But that kind of attack can never fully succeed — not really. Long after Mr. Rushdie, his attacker and the rest of us are gone, Mr. Rushdie’s works will remain and will be read. And that is about as close to immortality as any human being can come.
This barbarous act happened not just on American soil, but at the Chautauqua Institution — a place that for 150 years has celebrated the open and civilized exchange of ideas and that encourages artists to express themselves. It is anathema that it could happen in this place that welcomes all religions and promotes tolerance and respect. In those 30 harrowing seconds, our beloved Chautauqua has been forever changed.
For anyone who previously thought that this kind of thing cannot happen at Chautauqua, that illusion has been shattered. Nowhere is safe from violence of this sort, no person immune from its ravages.
What does that mean for us? For the Chautauqua Institution? How can we return to its amphitheater, this temple of free expression, now that blood has been spilt?
The answer is we cannot. And we have.
In the week since the attack, I and other audience members have returned to the Chautauqua amphitheater, and speakers and artists have returned to that stage, the blood washed clean, but it will never be quite the same place. If Mr. Rushdie recovers sufficiently, I hope he will want to return as well, to show that he is not easily silenced. He has taught us that part of the answer to terrorism is not to be terrorized.
What exactly has been sacrificed? Our idealism, for one thing. And good riddance. For even here, in this country, our freedoms are under attack. Defenders cannot just be idealists — they must be realists.
In the aftermath of this horror some of us will pick up our pens, or our prayer books, or our paintbrushes, and try in our own small ways to make sense of the horror we witnessed. The vast majority of us who were in the amphitheater that morning — and legions of others — will continue to defend the right of every human being to express themselves, in words, in art and in music.
Being open-minded, tolerant and respectful in our thoughts and actions is not good enough. Not nearly. We need to follow Mr. Rushdie’s example and be brave and fearless, but even that is not enough. We need to be smart and pragmatic. And much better prepared.
Meredith Mileti is a Pittsburgh writer, and the author of “Aftertaste: A Novel in Five Courses.” She was formerly on the faculty of the University of Pittsburgh, and she is a frequent visitor to the Chautauqua Institution.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.