There’s something wrong about the way we’ve discussed global climate change and the ways to avert it. It is unlikely that we will be able to reduce global greenhouse gas emission levels to the point that climate change would be averted. Last year, the Glasgow conference agreed that the current set of country-by-country pledges to reduce CO2 emissions won’t achieve the world’s climate temperature objectives, even if met.
If it’s unlikely, this nation and others would be wise to accelerate measures to address the impacts of climate change (called “adaptation” in climate change discussions) at least as much as reducing carbon footprints (called “mitigation”). Of course the earth is warming and there are air pollution benefits to replacing coal-fired power plants with solar, wind or natural gas-powered electric generation. But that’s not enough.
Why is it unlikely that the world will be able to reduce greenhouse gases enough? What matters is not the short-term greenhouse gas emissions from any one country. What matters is the total cumulative emissions across the entire globe. And one major nation will almost certainly not be reducing its production of greenhouse gases enough to help prevent climate change.
Since 2005, the USA has been surpassed by China as the world’s largest source of global greenhouse gas (mostly CO2) emissions. Since 2005, USA CO2 emissions have been reduced by about 21% while China’s have doubled.
Put simply, China’s CO2 emissions have increased more since 2005 than the entire current amount of CO2 emissions from the USA. Today, CO2 emissions from China exceed the combined total of all such emissions from the USA, the UK and the EU countries.
Despite attempts to reduce global CO2 emissions via international conferences, worldwide CO2 emissions and corresponding atmospheric concentrations have continued to increase.
Read More
Mathematically, China’s CO2 emissions are likely to continue to increase at least until 2030 based on their own stated objectives for CO2 control. China has set two major targets. First, they have pledged that their total CO2 emissions will peak by 2030. Secondly, they have set an objective of reducing their 2005 “carbon intensity” by 60-65% by 2030. They have defined carbon intensity as the ratio of CO2 emissions to Gross Domestic Product (GDP). So, as their economy grows, their CO2 emission target increases proportionately.
There are at least two major reasons for skepticism. First is that, as noted, global CO2 emissions have continued to rise despite some countries already reducing their own emissions just as they had pledged. Secondly, there is evidence that China, as the world’s largest CO2 emitter, is likely to continue increasing their emissions at least until 2030 — even if they meet the targets they have set.
Comparing China’s and the USA’s emissions can be done several ways. At present, the per capita rate of emissions (expressed as annual tons of CO2 emissions per person, TPP) is still greater in the USA than in China (8.3 for China vs. 13.9 for the USA).
In 2021, China’s TPP rate was only about 60% of the USA rate. If, as has already been happening in China, their TPP rate keeps increasing to even 80% of the current USA rate, the increased emissions from China would need to be offset by a 90% reduction in USA CO2 emissions just to break even on a global basis. In other words, no net global reduction even if USA emissions are reduced by 90%.
For another way to compare USA and China CO2 emissions, assume that China meets its goal of reducing their 2005 carbon intensity by 65% by 2030. Applying the 65% reduction factor to China’s 2005 carbon intensity and updating China’s GDP to 2030, it will take only a 0.30% annual increase in China’s GDP (from 2021 to 2030) to result in an increase in China’s 2030 emissions equaling 100% of current USA emissions.
China’s annual GDP growth has averaged around 7% from 2005-2021 and is projected to increase by about 5% annually through the mid-2020’s, so their calculated increase in CO2 emissions will easily exceed all such current USA emissions. If, as predicted, China’s GDP growth averages 5% through 2030, they would have to adjust their carbon intensity reduction target to 75% (from 2005) just to keep their increased CO2 emissions equal to 100% reduction from the USA.
China is unlikely to dramatically reduce its own carbon footprint. (This is true of several other countries as well.) The rising global concentrations of CO2 will affect the USA and other countries taking extraordinary measures to reduce their own CO2 emissions. The mitigation measures the USA is taking (e.g., eliminating fossil fuels) will likely increase the cost of energy for those who can least afford it, decrease the reliability of our energy supply and reduce our competitive position with China and other countries not reducing their levels as much as we are.
This is why we need to adapt as well as mitigate. What would be needed to adapt to climate change? It would include such measures as sea wall construction, enhanced irrigation, improved forest-fighting techniques and even expanded access to air conditioning.
New York City, San Antonio, and other cities have adopted measures to adapt to anticipated changes. However, most governmental policies concentrate on reducing dependence on fossil fuels, especially coal. Wouldn’t it make sense to focus at least as much on preparing for the effects?
Joseph Duckett has a PhD in Environmental Engineering and is a registered Professional Engineer in 6 states. He has worked in air pollution control for the past 50 years. He teaches air pollution control as an adjunct professor at the University of Pittsburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.