Dear Shadyside, Highland Park, Squirrel Hill, Lawrenceville and Other Neighbors: You’re next. Carson Street on the South Side saw another shooting the weekend before last, with nine rounds fired and a subsequent attempted homicide charge.
This, despite the hollow statements two months ago by Bruce Kraus, our local councilman, that he “is mad as hell” and is “not going to take it anymore.” Mayor Ed Gainey provided a firm commitment at the same meeting to “change the gun culture.”
The South Side Flats has gone from being a safe location for drunken college kids to being a location where citizens are regularly shot.
Businesses on Carson Street — The Vault, The Fudge Factory, Foxtail and others — are shuttering, with some owners publicly saying that the violence has forced them to make a hard choice between running a profitable enterprise and looking out for the safety of their employees.
Along with the South Side’s incredible architecture and naturally lush riverfront, these small firms underpin the vibrant culture that has made the area so appealing to new residents and new businesses alike. That culture is now imperiled by the inability of our city’s leaders to stem the violence.
The economic impacts won’t end with restaurants and bars closing on the South Side. As seen over and over in other cities, an economic death spiral takes hold. Businesses close, cultural attributes decline, neighborhoods become less interesting to new residents, more businesses close, more cultural attributes decline and so on.
Read More
The residents who form our burgeoning technology community — many of whom are recent transplants from places like San Francisco, New York and Boston — will determine that Pittsburgh isn’t the unique city that initially attracted them. At some point, they will decide there are safer cities with better economics, where they can send their kids to great schools, have outstanding cultural experiences and live without fear of being shot.
Moreover, the city will simply not attract future significant capital investments with this lawlessness and will not realize its full potential. New development will cease when investors realize that the models on which they based their investments are no longer supported by the local business mix. While these detrimental effects will be felt most acutely on the South Side in the near term, they will affect every Pittsburgh neighborhood as investment outlooks worsen.
To add even more frustration, homeowners recently received letters from the city reminding them that in this historic area, one block deep along each side of Carson Street, they can’t paint their homes an unapproved color nor replace their windows without authorized period designs. If the sidewalks around their homes are not maintained to the city’s satisfaction, a criminal complaint with an arrest warrant will be filed for the owner.
Yet the city can’t make carrying firearms into a bar a crime, in the exact same historic district. Nor can it impose a temporary moratorium on new liquor licenses, as evidenced by the large orange posters in storefronts showing even more applications for liquor licenses.
What the city does on the South Side is truly a litmus test for Pittsburgh as we look to the next decade for growth. Will we become New York City in the 1980s, or current day Chicago, overridden by crime to the point where anything other than the most heinous of offenses is ignored? Will we become Detroit, where there are neighborhoods in which the police won’t respond past a certain hour of the night for fear of their own safety?
Or will we find a way to quickly turn the tide, like Cincinnati did in its Over-the-Rhine neighborhood, now the home of Michelin-starred restaurants? (For what it’s worth, Ohio has state gun laws comparable to Pennsylvania, proving it is indeed possible.)
As citizens, there is precious little we can do to affect the outcome. The action required and ultimate results sit directly at the feet of our municipal leadership. The police force is responsive and professional but woefully understaffed and overwhelmed relative to magnitude of this problem.
An array of solutions was proposed by citizens at the June meeting with Mr. Gainey and Mr. Kraus, but change simply isn’t happening fast enough. Ask elderly residents on the South Side if they are afraid to venture out on the weekends, or if they would move if it were an option. Ask younger people if they take into consideration their safety when they go out on the South Side on the weekends, or if they debate alternate destinations.
This is a crucible moment for governance of our city and each of its citizens — one that city leadership won’t get a second chance to address.
Eric Gillespie is the founder of national security firm Govini and a resident of the South Side Flats.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.