CHAMPION, PA. — Sharon DiNicola is standing in line at Pletcher’s Farm Stand on Pennsylvania State Route 711 along with a dozen other customers; her wagon is filled with ripe tomatoes, green peppers, a dozen ears of corn, a large jug of Apple Cider, sugar onions and a half dozen cloves of garlic. As all the folks in line wait to check out, they engage in small talk about where they are from or what they are making from the vegetables and fruits they’re buying.
The couple behind DiNicola has two bushels of tomatoes, one bushel of green beans and a bushel of Chambersburg peaches — they are going to “put up” their haul to enjoy in the winter. The family behind them is holding a smaller basket of beets, cucumbers, a bouquet of sunflowers and several bottles of McCutcheon’s apple butter, grape jelly and Southern Peach vinaigrette dressing; they’re having family in this weekend.
DiNicola says she has been coming to Pletcher’s for as long as she can remember. “Brian and Tracey are the hardest workers I know,” the Acme resident says of the husband and wife team who keep this stand humming every year from April until Halloween.
“All of their vegetables and fruits are so fresh, and there is so much variety — not only do you get better quality and price coming here, for some reason you don’t meet new people standing in line at a big box grocery store in the way you do here,” she said. “The relationship you form with both the owners and the sense of community you feel just shopping here is why I come.”
For well over 100 years, some member of the Pletcher family has been selling crops along the side of the road here in Westmoreland County that connects East Wheatfield township to Connellsville — on the stretch of road that takes city folk fresh off the Pennsylvania Turnpike to tourist destinations like Seven Springs Ski Resort, Fallingwater and Ohiopyle State Park.
Farm stands have been an American staple since long before the invention of the automobile. That invention brought consumers from the larger towns and cities directly to the farmer.
Read More
The more artistic the display of fresh fruits, the more consumers the farmers attracted — and word of mouth spreads when you offer a quality product and quality service. The U.S. Department of Agriculture says farm stands and farmers markets contribute $9 billion each year to America’s economy. The number of them has quadrupling since 1994 — from fewer than 2,000 to more than 8,600, according to the Farmers Market Coalition.
Customers like DiNicola say they like Pletcher’s not just for the quality and the camaraderie, but also because one can stretch the family budget, thanks to Pletcher’s prices. With cost of preparing food at home having increased by 12.2 percent since June 2021, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Consumer Price Index, that stretching is important.
Brian Pletcher, his wife Tracey and son Jarrett are the fourth generation to run the farm stand. It has evolved from fresh corn, strawberries and other fruits and vegetables sold out of the back of his great-grandfather’s pick-up truck to the aisles of fresh vegetables, fruits, flowers and canned goods in and around several buildings today.
The farm stand has gone from vegetables and flowers from the family farm just over the mountain to Pletcher traveling throughout the state — as well as into parts of Ohio and Maryland — to other farms to give his customers a wide variety of options and good produce.
“I probably put 80,000 miles on my truck every year,” he said. “It is something I've been doing all my life, and because of that, we've built very good connections, very good relationships over the years; I go wherever I've got to go to get the best quality and the most local at the time.”
In the early part of the farm stand season — when the crops locally aren’t ready — Pletcher is in his big white truck with his dog Hunter trekking down to Florida, Georgia and other states, often making one-day trips just to get the fruit and vegetables on the tables at the stand for his customers.
“It's literally picked, put on a truck, and drove up here. At that point, that's as fresh as you're going to get,” he said.
Pletcher said his daily routine runs something like this: his wife Tracey gives Brian an inventory of what’s left in stock at the market. “I then make a list out of that and send it to my son. He loads all that stuff on the truck out of the cooler, which is on the farm, and he brings it down, and they display it. Meanwhile, I'm off buying stuff for the next day,” he explained. A process all three start at 5 a.m. every day.
And while the presentation is impeccable, it’s the signs — homemade and hand-written by Brian — that have the regulars smiling knowingly and give new customers a lesson in basic common sense.
Regulars call them “Brianisms.”
An annual favorite placed right in front of the rows of beautiful flowers that the family spends months growing in their greenhouse reads: “We absolutely do not guarantee plants. Some people just don’t have a green thumb. If it was planted since late January and beautiful when you bought it and dead a week later, then that tells you something.”
A personal favorite of the regulars standing in line reads: “PLEASE DO NOT COME UP TO US and tell us where you can buy something cheaper. We don’t care, and we work way too hard to listen to it. We will kindly tell you to go there then. If you don’t like a price, just quietly LEAVE. For those of you who don’t complain, we greatly appreciate your business. We couldn’t have done been here 30 plus years without you! Thanks.”
You don’t develop a deep loyalty with consumers without connecting with them and developing a relationship, without making sure what they see is of the highest quality — which is why Brian says the signs are necessary, even if they take no prisoners.
He smiles and blushes: “I don't know if it's right or wrong. It's just me. Believe me, I love my customers and we couldn't do it without them, but some people…” he says, his voice trailing off.
Pletcher said they go to extremes every single day to make sure they sell quality, spending hours every day making the vegetables and fruits are in perfect condition — only for some customer, usually a non-regular, to take every tomato out of the basket and squeeze it.
“It insults me. Maybe I shouldn't look at it that way, but my blood instantly boils — because we put a lot of effort and care into making sure that every tomato is good … and then you just waltz in here and throw them around, and dig through them, insinuating that we're hiding something in the bottom,” he said.
Worse yet, such customers damage the produce to the point that now they can’t sell them — which is why there are plenty of “Brianisms” by the tomatoes and peaches telling you not to handle or squeeze.
The other thing the market is famous for is nearly in season: the 1,300-pound ‘big pumpkin’ they place in the center of the stand every September — with plenty of signs along the local roads telling people to come and see him. “It is as close as we get to advertising,” Pletcher says, laughing.
Of all the direct marketing practices large companies attempt to attract customers, no one does it better than the farmer’s roadside stand — done well and right, the loyalty spans generations. They are not only often the heart of the community emotionally, they also contribute economically, directing their customers to other shops up and down the road.
As the couple with the bushels of tomatoes, peaches and green beans left the parking lot, the wife said, “We’ll take this day, and it will last with us all winter — that right there is the benefit few understand, but is the most rewarding.”
North Side native Salena Zito is a national political reporter for The Washington Examiner, a New York Post columnist and co-author of “The Great Revolt”: zito.salena@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.