ALTOONA, Pa. — The story of the American company town — the story of the people who lived and prayed and raised their families in them — can be told in no better place than here in Altoona.
The Pennsylvania Railroad was once the most powerful and wealthiest railroad in the world, and its factory was right here. During its heyday it employed over 17,000 people who turned out so many freight cars and cabooses that if you placed them back to back, they’d have stretched coast to coast.
The town sprang up around the rail business, which for the workers required grit, a wrench, brutal hours, a willingness to succeed and a belief that the industry would be around forever.
Except nothing is forever.
The transformation of rail from a local enterprise to a vital, national transportation network in the 1870s was a game changer: Technological advancements in communication, faster speeds, heavier freight cars and better traveling accommodations all combined to accelerate America’s Industrial Revolution.
The more innovative the railroads became, the more the country prospered: more workers, more travelers. Small towns like Ligonier, Ohiopyle, West Newton, Bedford and Roaring Springs flourished with shoppers and tourists — and their industries flourished as well.
Read More
Altoona, for its part, was once at the forefront of technological innovation. For instance, when the Horseshoe Curve was built here in the 1850s, the idea was considered impossible.
Altoona museum historian and curator Andrew Brumbaugh explains why they went for the impossible: “The Allegheny Mountains, standing over 2,100 feet above sea level, were a robust barrier to westward expansion in the 1850s. By using switchbacks, construction workers here — mostly Irish immigrants — lessened the grade of the mountains by creating this horseshoe shaped curve that allowed the trains to pass over it.”
That feat merged the east with the west and became known at the time as the “Eighth Engineering Wonder of the World.”
The railroads, however, were also notoriously poorly run. Historian Richard White chronicled the greed of railroad executives and the politicians who empowered them in his book, “Railroaded: The Transcontinentals and the Making of Modern America.”
Mr. White explains that the railroads were a vast Ponzi scheme that never made money: Lines were built in places they had no business being, and every so many years various railroad schemes threw the country into economic “panics” — today called “crashes” or “recessions.”
Even so, it wasn’t ineptitude that undid the railroads, but innovation: the automobile, the airplane and their associated infrastructure. By the late 1960s, the interstate highway system made driving cross country — or just a state or two away — far more convenient than it had been just ten years earlier.
Innovation gives, and innovation takes away.
That history, both the triumphs and the tragedies, has been honored by Altoona with a remarkably detailed railroad museum located on the site of the old Pennsylvania Railroad factory. In the 1960s, the city lobbied for the Pennsylvania Railroad Museum to be located here, but the bid failed. But Altoona rallied and built its own: the Altoona Railroaders Memorial Museum.
From the museum, a funicular takes you to a platform that offers sensational views of the famous Horseshoe Curve. As you wait for the next train to make its way up the mountains, you can hear the long-long-short-long whistle echoing off of the Alleghenies. It makes you mourn a past soured by politics and corruption, and lost to the next big things in technology.
Kevin Varrato, the president of the Steel City chapter of the Railway Historical Society, says he gets that a lot: “There is really a love/hate relationship with railroads. People love them for their nostalgia and get emotional when they see the glory of an old steam engine.”
Mr. Varrato explains that Western Pennsylvania has lost a lot of its railroad heritage: “It was a joy to catch the train to go into Pittsburgh. Just after WWII to 1964, there was a steady decline in upwards of 84% of non-commuter passenger travel. Most of this decline was due to the affordability and independence of owning your own car. You no longer had to live near your work; you could live in the suburbs and drive to work, to school, to strip malls, to anywhere, stop anywhere and have your own time schedule.”
In that process, a lot of small towns that had relied on rail service were left with only light commuter rail or buses. “The PAT Train or Mon Valley Commuter Rail, for example, ran from Pittsburgh to Versailles on the Baltimore and Ohio railroad line between 1975 to 1989,” Mr. Varrato said. “At its peak in 1981, over 1,800 people rode the PAT train daily, but ridership declined, and the project was discontinued on April 28, 1989.”
The decline in the rail industry since the 1940s has been steady, but not always gradual. The latest numbers from the Bureau of Labor Statistics show employment in the rail transportation industry — which was kept alive in large part because of the coal industry — began to crater in November of 2018. By December of 2020, the industry had lost 40,000 jobs in two years.
Those losses come from three main factors: the decline of the reliance on coal as a natural resource, an uncertain trade environment, and increases in efficiency.
Mr. Brumbaugh said the men and women who built the freight cars and cabooses and engines that came out of this town did so with pride. “They knew what they did made the country prosper,” he said, adding they also made Altoona prosper.
There was also an economic impact when the railroads stopped serving places like Roaring Springs, Ohiopyle, Ligonier or New Waterford, Ohio —those towns had to find a way to reinvent themselves or wither away. If they were located on a decent road network, they were fine — but they could also fall if a somewhat bigger town not far away had more services.
Railroads were once king, but the lesson here at the Altoona Railroaders Memorial Museum is that innovation and automation will always be the shadows that chase us, catch us and eventually pass us by.
In their heyday, the railroads not only provided good jobs and opened new markets, but also they also forced passengers — by necessity — to patronize local businesses when they spent the night at a stop. Those towns also suffered from the decline of the industry.
Today even the car and airplane have not kept up with another, handheld innovation: the smartphone. Who would have ever imagined we could work a good job and open up new markets without ever leaving the house?
The next time you hear the long-long-short-long whistle of the train, think about whether the trade-off was worth it.
North Side native Salena Zito is a national political reporter for The Washington Examiner, a New York Post columnist and co-author of “The Great Revolt”: zito.salena@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.