I must have looked so lost. It was my first time living in the city and I was all kinds of turned around. I have a very specific memory of my freshman year at Pitt, standing in front of the Litchfield Towers, the scent of The O’s fries coming up from Bouquet St.

A stranger came up to me, and asked if I needed help. I told her I was just trying to get to Market District. Before I could say another word, she had fished a notepad and pen out of her purse, wrote down which buses I could take (“The 71A, 71C, 75, or P3 will all get you there, hon”).

I had only been in Pittsburgh for a few weeks, and yet the city was already showing me what it meant to be a neighbor here. It wasn’t just a nice reference to Mr. Rogers, it was a part of the culture. If the city is known for one thing, it’s for being a city of neighborhoods and of friendly neighbors.

But now legislation making its way through Congress would betray the values of this neighborly culture of ours. Back in March 2020, when the pandemic first hit America, the government activated a statute called Title 42 that allowed border agents to turn back some migrants from crossing our southern border.

Advertise with us

Under this policy, asylum seekers can be turned back without even having a chance to ask for help. The initial idea was that this policy would limit the spread of COVID-19, but the Centers for Disease Control already tried to end this policy months ago.

Some people are trying to keep Title 42 in place, whether through the courts or through Congress. They argue that removing the policy would mean migrants overwhelming the southern border.

A problem with that argument is that Title 42 creates more traffic at the southern border. People turned back under Title 42 try again and again, which only increases the number of encounters at the border. As many as 1 in 3 encounters are with people entering again after being turned away under this policy.

These additional encounters force Border Patrol agents to waste their valuable time and resources and does nothing to address any underlying issues. As many public health experts have argued since this policy began, there is no public health benefit to Title 42. Also, the policy doesn’t reduce the traffic at the border and it doesn’t prevent drugs from entering our country. It does nothing but immediately turn some people away from the border without hearing their story.

Title 42 is the wrong tool for the job: it’s like using the claw of a hammer to get popcorn out of your teeth — all you really need is a toothpick.

Advertise with us

But more importantly, Title 42 betrays our values as Pittsburghers. This whole city has a neighborly, helping culture, and it’s a large part of why I’m proud to call Pittsburgh home.

Turning someone away before they even have the opportunity to ask for help — whether it’s a lost teen in front of Litchfield Towers or someone at our border — it contradicts what it means to be a Pittsburgher.

Despite this, some politicians in Pittsburgh continue to advocate on a national level to maintain Title 42. Two local congressmen — Democrat Conor Lamb and Republican Mike Kelly — have co-sponsored a bill extending Title 42. While that bill has stalled, amendments doing the exact same thing are actively being considered. These politicians are saying to us they want to continue preventing asylum seekers from asking for help when they need it most.

What Pittsburgh has shown me time and time again is that being a neighbor means taking action when someone needs your help. So let’s be neighborly, and end Title 42.

Jesse Dubin is a program evaluator at the University of Pittsburgh addressing the opioid epidemic in Pennsylvania.