Last week, on the same day that another community member lost his life in the Allegheny County Jail, the Post-Gazette published an op-ed by Warden Orlando Harper complaining that the media ignore his jail’s alleged “successes.”
Victor Zilinek, who died a day after he was booked, was 39. His death is far from any notion of “success.”
Any time we lose a member of our community in the jail, it is an unmitigated tragedy that deserves a thorough and detailed investigation. That’s especially true with a facility that the Post- Gazette Editorial Board has criticized for staffing shortages and inadequate mental and medical health care.
So far this year, four of our neighbors have lost their lives. That makes 15 deaths since March, 2020. Even so, the jail administration continues to stonewall every attempt at effective oversight.
Contrary to what Warden Harper claimed in his op-ed, the death rate in the Allegheny County Jail is nearly twice the national average. To make this mistake, Warden Harper may have used, for the jail’s population, the total annual intake, instead of its average daily population — which is what the U.S. Bureau of Justice uses. Using the annual intake number lowers the death rate considerably, because, with people cycling in and out of the jail, it’s much higher.
When you compare apples with apples, the jail’s death rate is twice the national death rate. Allegheny County Jail had 337 deaths per 100,000 people. That rate is based on six deaths in 2021 and an average daily population of 1,780. Those numbers are included in Allegheny County Jail’s own population dashboard.
Read More
This year, If nothing changes, we are on track to have an even higher death rate.
The team that calculated the incorrect death rate was either unaware of the mistake or acting deceptively — and that’s part of the problem.
Instead of investing in solutions, Allegheny County has used taxpayer dollars to create a jail Twitter account and hire a self-described communications specialist. We cannot tweet our way to fewer jail deaths; we cannot solve the problem if we refuse to acknowledge it.
I know, firsthand, that the warden has misled the public about conditions in the jail. In 2016, I was incarcerated in the Allegheny County Jail for substance use disorder. I detoxed from opioids without proper medical care, on the floor of a cell likely identical to the one that Victor passed through a few hours before his death.
Fortunately, I was later able to enter and remain in recovery for substance use disorder. In 2019, I was elected to Allegheny County Council as one of two at-large representatives. Shortly after I was sworn into office in January 2020, I became Council President Pat Catena’s designee on the Jail Oversight Board.
Since then,15 deaths have occurred at the Allegheny County Jail. I’m running out of words for the ongoing tragedy that is unfolding daily. Neither County Executive Rich Fitzgerald nor Warden Orlando Harper seem to be particularly worried about the death trap over which they have direct authority and direct responsibility.
Instead, their focus has been to use county tax dollars to shut down any attempt at investigation, transparency and accountability. Meantime, legal fees and settlements keep adding up for county taxpayers, and conditions continue to worsen for those inside.
When evaluating the jail, I sometimes quote the words of Steelers Head Coach Mike Tomlin: “We are what our record says it is.”
The Allegheny County Jail’s own statistics — when not misrepresented by the administration — demonstrate an abnormally high death rate that reflects gross mismanagement and opens the county to ongoing moral, legal and financial liability.
Rather than complaining about the negative news coverage demonstrating incompetence and mismanagement within the jail, Warden Harper and County Executive Fitzgerald should actually address the problems that fuel it.
Bethany Hallam is an at-large Allegheny County Councilor and the Council President’s designee on the Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.