Pennsylvania’s current probation system is big government bureaucracy at its worst. It’s no shock that it fails to make Pennsylvanians safer. The system actually makes our state less safe, in addition to disrupting lives and costing a fortune.
Our state’s lawmakers have a rare opportunity to hit a grand slam: reduce the crime rate, expand our workforce, save taxpayer dollars, and help people in the criminal justice system reintegrate, all at once.
I’m a conservative, and I believe the Assembly should urgently prioritize Senate Bill 913, offering comprehensive probation reform. It’s a bipartisan no-brainer: a more robust set of sensible, evidence-based, public safety-focused measures that would dramatically improve our state's probation system.
At the end of 2020, Pennsylvania had about 112,000 people on probation and was one of the few states that saw that number increase that year. Our state supervises about 25 percent more people than the national average.
And the state’s supervision terms are also remarkably long, with 10- and 20-year sentences not uncommon. This is entirely too long and has failed to accomplish its goal — to reduce recidivism.
The evidence is strong that the public safety benefits of supervision drop dramatically after the first few years of a person’s sentence. Longer terms of supervision actually seem to make future crime more likely.
Read More
A recent study by the Pennsylvania Commission on Sentencing found that almost 88% of the studied probation cases in which the person was resentenced involved a technical violation, such as leaving the county or missing a meeting. Many individuals are sentenced to county jail or prison.
Sending people back to jail for technical violations represents not only a staggering cost to affected families, but also to taxpayers. Each prison readmission costs the state over $40,000 per year. Rather than using this money to lock people up for breaking a curfew, Pennsylvania could be using this money to address violent crime.
Worse, the cycle of reincarceration and release for technical violations makes it harder for people on probation to do the things we know reduce recidivism and increase public safety. These include getting and keeping a job, accessing drug treatment, finding stable housing, and building family and community ties. Pennsylvania’s current probation system actually makes our state less safe, in addition to disrupting lives and costing a fortune.
SB 913, authored by State Senator Liz Baker and passed by the Senate 46-4 with overwhelming support from the Republican caucus, aims to reform this system to reduce these costs, while preserving public safety. To start, the bill favors early termination of probation for people who have successfully completed three years (for misdemeanors) or five years (for felonies).
Proceeding on the key conservative principle that incentives work, the bill also gives people on probation clear incentives to do things that we know reduce recidivism and are some of the best possible hedges against future crime: get a college degree or a GED, get and keep a job, get job training, or engage in community service. It gives those who complete these activities quicker consideration for early termination.
The bill also caps the amount of time individuals can be incarcerated for the first or second violation and lets judges require time to be served on the weekends and non-work days, so people can keep their jobs. It reforms responses to unpaid criminal fines and fees, which have often been a cause for unnecessary extensions of supervision and reincarceration for inability to pay.
An important byproduct of this bill: By safely reducing the number of people who don’t need to be on probation, we can reduce overburdened probation officers’ caseloads, freeing up precious law enforcement resources. Supervision best practices state that probation officers should supervise no more than 50 moderate to high-risk persons each.
In Pennsylvania, caseloads are about 105 per officer. In Delaware and Montgomery counties, they have exceeded 170 per officer. By purging those who don’t need further supervision from the system, we free officers to focus on high-risk individuals who need more intensive monitoring. That helps reduce the likelihood of future crime.
These reforms aren’t just a leap into the dark. Since 2017, York County District Attorney David Sunday, a conservative prosecutor, has run a program that makes some people on probation eligible for early termination once they’ve completed two years or 50% of their supervision sentence.
Of the more than 700 people who have had their probation terminated early, only around 8 percent recidivated — in a county where recidivism historically trends between 35 and 40 percent. Victims of crime are involved in the process, and termination requires court approval. But the program shows the power of incentives to help people stay on course.
I believe that public safety is the most critical duty of government. I reject empty-headed criminal justice reforms that don’t recognize the importance of punishment and deterrence. But a sensible criminal justice system also rewards compliance and the hard work of personal rehabilitation. Senate Bill 913 holds these important principles in balance, and would benefit everyone — crime victims, perpetrators, law enforcement, and taxpayers.
Jim Schultz is a lawyer practicing in Philadelphia and a former general counsel to Gov. Tom Corbett and White House ethics counsel.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.