Fracking is an industrial process. It involves not just the drilling rig, but other heavy equipment (pumper, cement, and mixer trucks; sand, water, and chemical containers). These don’t magically appear, but need to be moved on and off site.

There is noise, toxic air emissions, and truck traffic, during the pad preparation, drilling, and fracking. There is also the associated infrastructure such as compressor stations and processing facilities. Once the wells are in production, the tanks storing the produced water generated by the wells need to be serviced regularly (more truck traffic and emissions). County Council heard testimony from residents living near Deer Lakes about their experiences.

County Executive Rich Fitzgerald had it wrong in rejecting Allegheny County Council’s bill that restricts fracking, as well as other industrial activities, in our county parks. So did the Post-Gazette in its editorial “Fitzgerald is right to veto fracking ban.”

Both claimed that fracking under public land will not affect the land because the fracking equipment will sit outside it. There can be negative impacts whether the well pad is inside or outside of a park.

Advertise with us

My research group took samples monthly at seven different sites in Deer Lakes Park before, during and after fracking, and did indeed document changes in water chemistry of the lakes over that time. These included an increase in mine drainage in certain areas of the park as well as the detection of ethane, propane, butane and surfactants only after the drilling had commenced. The results from that study were presented to County Council.

We’ve also done a study at Cross Creek Lake in Washington County, where there are well pads inside the park. There we saw evidence for contamination downstream of the well pads long after the wells had been fracked. We attribute that contamination to drilling wastes that were allowed to be buried on site.

There were fish kills in 2009, 2015, and 2017. The first was attributed to a spill at one of the well pads, but the cause of the other two remains in question. Further, acres of parkland in and around the pads are now off limits to the public.

You also have to look at the long term. The wells at Deer Lakes and the airport are already in decline. Our study of unconventional well production in Washington County confirmed the dramatic decline curves typical for Marcellus wells (about 75% in the first year). By 2018, 126 wells were already either inactive or plugged.

Pennsylvania allows companies to charge the landowner when the production costs exceed the royalty payments. The County’s recent agreement with CNX includes this provision. I have met people who are writing checks to a drilling company to cover the difference. Companies can declare bankruptcy and abandon the wells. Do Allegheny County tax payers want to be stuck with paying for production and plugging costs?

Advertise with us

The county does not own all the mineral rights in the parks. Fitzgerald considered mining for coal in South Park, but a feasibility study done by Skelly and Loy Inc found the costs weren’t worth the financial gain. Only a few years earlier, when Dan Onorato was County Executive, the County had successfully blocked a mineral rights owner from strip mining in the same park.

Opening up industrial development in the parks may expose the county to lawsuits from other mineral rights holders. For now the parks are protected as green spaces for the common good.

Are the risks of environmental and health impacts and financial liability worth the short term gain? The parks are a cherished resource in their own right. We need to protect them, not exploit them.

John Stolz is the director for the Center for Environmental Research and Education and professor of environmental microbiology at Duquesne University.