The Republican Party in the Trump era remained a mostly pro-business party in its policies, but its constituencies and rhetoric have tilted more working class and populist, with many Romney Republicans drifting into the Democratic coalition. Meanwhile, the Democratic Party remains generally the party of regulation and higher taxation, but much of corporate America has swung culturally into liberalism’s camp.
Much of the GOP elite wish to continue doing business with big business as before. But the party’s base regards corporate institutions — especially in Silicon Valley, but extending to more traditional capitalist powers — as cultural enemies, with too much consolidated power and too much interest in pressuring, censoring and propagandizing against socially conservative views and policy. What does the right do when big business turns against conservatism?
One answer is the Elon Musk solution: You wait for a libertarian billionaire (or maybe really a billionaire with the politics of a liberal from 10 years ago — but look, conservatives have to take what they can get) to buy one of the companies whose mix of influence and censorship you fear. Suffice it to say that he would have to do a lot to make his kind of billionaire-savior model a real answer to conservatism’s general alienation from big business.
Which brings us to the second answer, the Ron DeSantis solution, manifest in the Florida governor’s recent war with Disney. You tell corporations that if they decide to become active on the liberal side of the culture wars, they may find their special deals and corporate carve-outs suddenly threatened or revoked.
There is a conservative case for the principle of what he’s doing — a case that while the government can’t single you out for special disfavor for your political speech, what is being withdrawn in Disney’s case is special favor, linked to the bipartisan and indeed above-partisanship position that the House of Mouse has long enjoyed in Florida.
Interestingly, this argument feels like a reworking, from the cultural right, of Elizabeth Warren’s argument from a decade back. She argued that nobody builds a business alone, and now conservatives are embracing a variation of that case — not to justify progressive taxation, but to suggest that if your business or institution accepts special government favors, then the public becomes a stakeholder in your success, and it has the right to withdraw that special treatment if you then become a partisan or ideological actor.
Read More
“Almost every institution the left controls and has weaponized in the culture wars,” conservative writer and editor Ben Domenech argued this week, “was created by and depends upon special, favorable treatment — even funding — from all Americans.”
This is true of public entities, public schools and universities, the locus of so much controversy right now, but it’s also true of the internet behemoths, beneficiaries of a regulatory system that largely immunized them from content responsibility (via the famous Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act). Or the Wall Street firms bailed out in 2008. Or the sports leagues that rely on antitrust exemptions and stadium subsidies. Or Disney — because, as Mr. Domenech writes, “it’s only by the generosity of the American people” that Disney has been successful in its decades of lobbying to extend copyright protections.
All of these institutions enjoy First Amendment protections from being discriminated against, this line of argument suggests. But forms of discrimination that work in their favor — meaning all their privileges, immunities and tax breaks — are political fair game if they enter the culture-war arena.
I don’t know if this argument is constitutionally convincing when applied to something as crudely retaliatory-seeming as the DeSantis move. But it’s convincing at some level of distance.
For instance, when the Trump administration pushed through a tax on endowment income for wealthy colleges and universities, that was clearly not just disinterested policy; the goal was to reduce the special treatment offered to these institutions precisely because they have grown increasingly radicalized against conservatism in recent years. It was a political act, a punitive one: You take tax dollars from conservatives as well as liberals, so you can’t complain when the right notices you don’t seem to hire any conservative faculty and decides to take some of those tax dollars back. And while there were claims that this intention made the measure unconstitutional, few legal figures seemed to take them particularly seriously.
So while the specific details of the Disney gambit may not be upheld or replicated, the idea behind it is likely to live on, shaping conservative ambitions at the state and federal level alike. (Especially since, as we saw with the Chick-fil-A wars, liberals are ready to engage in the same tactics when the opportunity presents itself — though the cultural weakness of the right means there are fewer high-profile opportunities.)
Most likely, given the chaotic nature of conservatism at the moment, these anti-corporate gambits will be tactical more often than strategic, symbolic more often than transformative, and quite often just showy gestures to the party’s business-skeptical base that leave cozy relationships intact behind the scenes.
But it’s still a striking evolution, that the right that once disdained an “actually, we all built that” account of business success is now inclined to adopt its own version of that case. And while I don’t expect Elizabeth Warren to claim any kind of vindication, it’s proof that ideas can circulate and reappear sometimes in the last place that you’d expect.
Ross Douthat is a columnist for The New York Times.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.