You may be surprised to find that some people believe that Ebeneezer Scrooge is a hero — the pre-ghost, pre-enlightened Ebeneezer Scrooge, that is. You may be shocked to find that many of them believe that Mr. Potter is the real good guy in “It’s a Wonderful Life.”

The first argue that Scrooge before the three ghosts showed him what a horrible man he was, benefited more people through his business than he did after he changed. Some even claim that he was a better man then, and that the post-ghost Scrooge only made things worse by encouraging the poor in their shiftless ways. He should have fired Bob Cratchit rather than helping him and his family. (I am not making that up.)

The second argue that Potter had created all the good things in Pottersville through his business and that in the real world George Bailey would have destroyed the town and the lives of the people in it. Hard-nosed buying and selling, that’s the way to make things work, no matter who gets hurt.

If you want a war on Christmas, there it is.

Advertise with us

It’s fair to say that Charles Dickens and Frank Capra don’t recognize the good that buying and selling does, and the extent to which free markets create broad prosperity. People have to have money to give money. You can’t use either story in an economics class. The Scrooge-Potter fan club isn’t completely wrong.

But they get very wrong a truth about human society, which we might call the Christmas idea. That is that every human being matters, not a little but completely and ultimately. No one’s a thing. No one’s good can be sacrificed to abstract principles and theories. If the Creator of the universe comes to us as a baby, permanently joins the human race, he makes everyone his brother and sister, and you don’t treat God’s brother and sister as a thing.

You can believe the idea even if you don’t believe the story of Jesus’s birth. It has other bases than the Christian one.

When I was growing up, the most politicized people tended to think of some people as things. The rightwing claimed that feeding starving people helped leftwing governments control them, because well-fed people don’t rebel. The leftwing claimed that feeding starving people helped rightwing governments control them, because well-fed people don’t rebel. So don’t feed them.

This wasn’t a stupid argument, but I think it was a barbaric one. It meant you were happy to sacrifice living human beings for a hoped-for future when your side finally wins. In the meantime — however many generations that might be — men, women and children must die in agony because someday, maybe, possibly, other people would have better lives. So would say the pre-enlightened Scrooge and the never-enlightened Potter.

Advertise with us

That child who hasn’t eaten for days? That baby who can’t nurse because her mother is too hungry to give milk? That father who doesn’t eat so his children will have what little he has? Tough luck, kids! Them’s the breaks. We’ve got to sacrifice you so the new world — libertarian or socialist — will someday arrive in all its glory. Ok, maybe it won’t, but we’re willing for you to take the risk.

The other day I came across a line from someone apparently of the Scrooge-Potter fan club, who said that those in what Catholics call the religious life, like nuns and monks, “would be better off learning how to build and run factories than engage in the life of the religious." He gave as examples those who work with the poor, especially the very poor.

The question, the Christmas question, if you will, is: What then would happen to the people they care for? People who are every bit as much Jesus’s brother or sister as those working in the Scrooge-Potter tradition of business unconcerned for individual human beings.

Lots of them would fail, because lots of businesses fail, and their businesses would fail even more often because most would feel bound to conduct their business by the Christmas idea. Some, alas, would succeed but by harming people, because business sometimes requires you to hurt people in order to succeed.

All in all, they probably wouldn't add much to human happiness. And they would not be adding what they would have added had they gone into the religious life.

Advertise with us

While they were in business, the people they once served would suffer, and their numbers would grow. Though since so many would be the least of these, without any economic value, they wouldn't much affect the Scroogian-Potterite calculations. That, again, is a real war on Christmas.

David Mills is the associate editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. He can be reached at dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “The parental delusion of sad beige parenting.”