The Biden administration is reportedly preparing a "war room" to deal with an unprecedented surge of migrants this summer, with the number of daily border crossers expected to jump from the current, already near-record level of 7,000 per day to over 18,000 daily.
Such a surge would be disastrous for almost everyone involved. Hospitals and social services in border towns are already strained and could collapse entirely this summer. The migrants themselves face dangerous conditions on their journeys, and then will face more abuse after they reach the United States and put themselves at the mercy of unscrupulous employers. And the massive influx will also hurt working-class Americans and legal immigrants by increasing competition for jobs and housing.
Folks on the left, like me, ought to be aghast. Unless the Biden administration addresses the underlying "pull factors" drawing migrants here, this human suffering will continue unabated.
Multiple presidential commissions have identified the "jobs magnet" as the primary attractant. Migrants from developing countries know they can earn far more here in America, even working under-the-table jobs for minimum or subminimum wages, than in their home countries.
Just like anyone else, migrants weigh the costs and benefits before making major decisions. They know the risks of illegally immigrating are relatively minor once they make it across the border. That's especially true now that the Biden administration announced an end to workplace raids by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement, all but guaranteeing that once people are here illegally, they can work without being deported. John Sandweg, President Obama's director of ICE, admitted that the likelihood that an ordinary illegal immigrant would be deported was "close to zero."
Corporations eagerly hire cheap, exploitable migrant labor to break strikes, weaken unions, and force employees of all nationalities and backgrounds to accept lower wages and worse working conditions. This abuse is why, until relatively recently, many folks on the left railed against illegal immigration.
Read More
Legendary labor activist Cesar Chavez famously condemned it. Former President Obama, probably the most talented politician in living memory, noted, "The idea that we can just have open borders is something that … as a practical matter, is unsustainable."
Sen. Bernie Sanders, in 2015, emphasized the need for limits on immigration. He decried open borders as a "Koch brothers proposal,” referring to the billionaire libertarians who believe almost nothing should restrict businesses. Open Borders would "make a lot of Americans poorer" and lead to a glut of desperate people who'd "work for $2 or $3 an hour."
Multiple peer-reviewed studies have confirmed the validity of their concerns, and proven that a massive expansion of the labor pool drives down wages, especially for minority workers.
So it's no wonder that ordinary voters, including those on the left, support measures to ensure that jobs only go to Americans and legal immigrants. For instance, 58% of Democrats want to "mandate that all employers use the federal electronic E-Verify system to help ensure that they hire only legal workers for U.S. jobs," according to a Rasmussen poll taken in late March.
The Biden administration could simultaneously protect workers and strike a blow against greedy employers — including the Trump Organization, which has infamously used illegal labor in the past — by getting behind an E-Verify requirement.
Unfortunately, the administration is doing the opposite. From ending the deterrent of workplace raids, to lifting the Title 42 restrictions that allow Border Patrol agents to quickly deport people who cross illegally, to dangling promises of another mass legalization, the administration is only enticing more people to come here.
That's not just a foolish policy — but a callous one, too.
Getting here is no cakewalk. Migrants usually rely on "coyotes" — dangerous smugglers who are known to abandon their charges in the wilderness — to get them across the harsh desert. Women and children are particularly vulnerable. Rape and sexual violence are common. Yet the pull of the jobs magnet is still strong enough to convince millions to brave this dangerous journey.
There's nothing progressive about tolerating a status quo that results in sexual assaults, avoidable deaths from exposure, overwhelmed social services and deplorable working conditions for migrants — and lower wages and higher rents for Americans and legal immigrants already here. The Biden administration can avert a catastrophe this summer simply by introducing common sense measures, like universal E-Verify, to deter illegal hiring and migration.
Jonette Christian is a founder of Mainers for Sensible Immigration Policy.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.