First there was the 1850 Charles Dickens classic novel, “The Personal History, Adventures, Experience and Observation of David Copperfield the Younger of Blunderstone Rookery (Which He Never Meant to Publish on Any Account).”

It offered a colorful admixture of the kind of shadowy, heroic, sinister and zany denizens that typically populate Dickens’ stories.

This coming-of-age novel, set in Victorian England in and around London and the seashore, is narrated by the title character as a child and young man. “To begin my life at the beginning of my life, I record that I was born ...,” launches the semiautobiographical tale.

Prior to 2019, there were some 13 feature films, television productions and animated presentations of “Copperfield.” Numerous adaptations and readings, including by even Dickens himself, preceded radio productions well into the 20th century.

Advertise with us

It is the captivating stark black-and-white 1935 Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer film with big-name Hollywood stars — in addition to the masterfully crafted book — to which I compare the 2019 version that premiered in Pittsburgh last month. “The Personal History of David Copperfield,” in a wink and nod to the British empire extant when the novel was written, offers a British rainbow-coalition cast of diverse racial backgrounds.

Whether the British novelist turned in his grave or smiled as an approving apparition is unknown.

Upon returning to the United Kingdom from his first visit to America — including time in Pittsburgh — in 1842, Dickens published “American Notes for General Circulation.” Chapter XVII is a plagiarized attack on slavery; his record on race matters “was rather more problematic,” according to the United Kingdom Arts and Humanities Research Council.

No matter. The Fox Searchlight producers of the 2019 film wagered that the flick would work with an Asian Mr. Wickfield (Benedict Wong), his black daughter (Rosalind Eleazar), a white James Steerforth (Aneurin Barnard), Steerforth’s black mother (Nikki Amuka-Bird), a very pale Copperfield mother and Copperfield love interest Dora Spenlow (Morfydd Clark as both) and — most bold of all — a Hindu Indian as the adult David Copperfield (Dev Patel).

These racial heritage representatives — British all — of far-flung parts of an empire on which the sun once never set did their best with the script that was handed to them.

Advertise with us

But two challenges conspired against their success. This latest adaptation of the book presented a screenplay that did not try hard enough to be Dickensian and, alas, was not Dickensian enough.

Further, the cast was simply not the mesmerizing Lionel Barrymore, W.C. Fields, Edna Mae Oliver, Basil Rathbone, Freddy Bartholomew, et al., directed by George Cukor from the 1935 film.

The most recent cinematic version of Dickens’ favorite novel converted the melodramatic 624-page story of wealth, poverty, child abuse, betrayal, friendship, deception and, of course, the British class distinctions into a satirical English romp.

In the book and the 1935 film, humor is injected with economy. The devices employed by Mr. Micawber — played flawlessly by Fields — in the evasion of creditors and his optimism that “something will turn up” before he goes to debtors prison, do elicit chuckles. Copperfield relative Mr. Dick and his unhinged appearance and utterances are amusing as well.

But, the dramedy characteristic of this newest “Copperfield” offends the biting social commentary that the aforementioned versions project.

Advertise with us

Several critics weighing in on the 2019 film gush over the perfection of the colorblind cast, and it is serviceable for sure. But it is about 85 years too late.

One might regard the scene-stealing Bartholomew as the actual young David Copperfield, not merely a child actor playing him in 1935. One could, except for Jairaj Varsani, that is. Cast as the preteen orphan in 2019, the 10 year-old Hindu Punjabi steals every fortunate scene in which he appears, and I crown him the new real David Copperfield as a youngster.

The nonhuman stars of the 2019 “Copperfield” are the wearables. The dazzling tartan plaids, waistcoats, wing collars for the British gentlemen as well as the period britches and other cool low-brow raiments of the cockneys create a classic cosmic visual effect worthy of an Oscar for costume design for Suzie Harman and Robert Worley.

Possible prescient casting of 2019 “Copperfield” rendered plausible an Asian man presented as the biological father of an obviously black daughter. Days before the film’s American premiere, the Democratic Party nominated the Asian/​African American daughter of British Commonwealth immigrants from India and Jamaica, Kamala Harris, for vice president of the United States. Life mirroring art mirroring life?

Robert Hill is a Pittsburgh-based communications consultant.