I’ve had occasion in recent days to think about the meaning of the word “emergency.”
Webster’s New World Dictionary defines it as “a sudden, generally unexpected occurrence or set of circumstances demanding immediate action.”
The intrepid, never-say-die state Attorney General Josh Shapiro has been mum, as of this writing, on his next courtroom maneuver, but there are reports he may ask Commonwealth Court to freeze in time the consent decree between UPMC and Highmark due to the “emergency” nature of the situation. The decree otherwise will expire June 30.
Some legal eagles in the community have opined that Mr. Shapiro would have a rough row to hoe in meeting the legal test for an emergency: Too few people are impacted and, those who are, had time enough to prepare for the coming End Times.
These sideline spectators should talk to a few of the people I’ve heard from...
There’s Judy, a Highmark patient at UPMC Hillman Cancer Center who breathed a heavy sigh of relief when UPMC made an 11th-hour about-face on June 6 and pronounced that Hillman would be open on an in-network basis to Highmark patients post-June 30. Then, when she tried to set up an appointment for her ongoing treatment, the office advised her to think twice and check with her insurer first. She called her insurer, who told her things are too iffy to give any assurance of in-network pricing. I reached out to Highmark and was told the same thing: There’s nothing nailed down. UPMC has delivered proposed terms but no agreements have been struck. Given the vitriolic history between the warring titans, there’s good reason to doubt there will be a resolution by June 30.
And the clock ticks.
Then there’s Randy. He’s a transplant patient with Highmark insurance and UPMC doctors. He needs lifelong care and tending and is among the “medically fragile” covered by the consent decree. He wrote to me a few days ago to convey his congratulations to the cancer patients who, fingers-crossed, won’t face a disruption in care come July 1, but he also expressed the wish that he, too, could hold on to the doctors who know his case and his body best. Is there any hope for him?
And the clock ticks.
Then there’s Nadine, another Hillman cancer patient under active treatment. She’s happy she now won’t lose her cancer doctors but is perplexed about the status of her “team” members at Shadyside (under the same roof as Hillman, by the way). Will they be scooped into the new contract between Hillman and Highmark? She’s confused and can’t get a straight answer. Will it come before she needs her next appointment?
And the clock ticks.
• • •
I’m no lawyer, but I have a general understanding of the English language and I’m hearing emergency sirens.
The stakes couldn’t be higher: life and health.
Certainly, immediate action is required as the consent-decree deadline now is days away.
As for the “sudden” or “generally unexpected” components of Webster’s definition of emergency, I say yes, but some would argue.
Some have argued.
Case in point:
A few months back, I sat across a table from UPMC’s mouthpiece-in-chief. He was selling his message, slick as a used-car salesman. I bit my tongue (mostly) as I listened to him explain why the June 30 ending of the consent decree simply wasn’t news.
He coldly — while smiling — observed that the split with Highmark happened “years ago” when Highmark subscribers who weren’t already under treatment with UPMC were restricted from in-network access beginning in 2014. As for the elderly and the medically fragile, they had a five-year reprieve. A five-year warning.
Here’s what the UPMC master spinmeister didn’t get: No one believed it would really happen.
The five-year period wasn’t a five-year warning of what was coming so much as a five-year period for UPMC and Highmark to figure things out — or for someone powerful to make them figure things out.
Surely, our local officials — Mayor Bill Peduto and county Executive Rich Fitizgerald — would rally the troops, we thought.
And if not them, our state lawmakers would weigh in, we thought.
And if not them, our congressional delegation would turn up the heat, we thought.
And if not the congressional delegation, then the state health department, or the state insurance department, or the federal justice department or the region’s business leaders, we thought.
And if not them or those, perhaps UPMC CEO Jeffrey Romoff would grow a heart or his board of directors would grow a spine and make him grow a heart, we thought.
Or ... well, you get my drift.
In sum, I contend that the June 30 drop-dead date is indeed sudden as well as generally unexpected.
And we’ve got an emergency situation here. Just ask Judy, Randy and Nadine.
Karen Kane is a Post-Gazette editorial board member (kkane@post-gazette.com, 724-772-9180, Twitter: @KarenKanePG).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.