Received Thursday, this is one of many emails sent by readers to Karen Kane. It has been edited for length.
•
Beth is the consummate American: politically active; she researches issues; she reads; she’s an entrepreneur. She’s my friend and my co-worker. Twenty years ago, she came to my law office with a proposal to set up her own company to provide services for me and other local lawyers, so she is known in the public buildings and courtrooms of Allegheny and Washington counties. She is highly motivated. She and her partner bought a home in the city because they believe in the city and they have invested countless amounts of time and money in their home. They support the arts and can regularly be seen walking their rescue dogs through the streets of Brookline. They are part of a neighborhood, a city, a state and a country. Her nieces, nephews and charities know the love and largesse of Aunt Beth.
For the past seven years, I have watched her deal with her pain. Years of testing, two surgeries on her neck and brain. Pain so severe that she had to wear ear muffs in the summer, lest an errant breeze find her ear and drive her to her knees in agony. She has attacked her condition with the drive and single-mindedness she brings to every facet of her life. After five and a half years and countless doctors, cancer was diagnosed. This past January, she endured 14 hours on the operating table and three months of five-times-per-week radiation. As her friends, we took turns taking her because it was pretty much all that we could do. She came back to work a short time after the radiation treatments ended.
During all the time that she has been suffering, one constant has been the endless calls with insurers. She has Highmark insurance in the UPMC Kingdom that Allegheny County has become. It was the UPMC doctors who diagnosed and operated on her cancer and now she faces the June 30 deadline and soon may have to drive to Cleveland to receive the same medical care that is an 18-minute drive from her home.
On May 14, she and others like her went to Harrisburg to lobby legislators over a bill to resolve this issue that has been stuck in the lawmaking labyrinth that is the country’s most bloated state legislature. She found that state House Speaker Mike Turzai holds the bill in limbo. When she went to his office, Pennsylvania’s own Mitch McConnell wannabe didn’t have the time to come out and even acknowledge her. I stood behind her on the steps in Harrisburg as she and others told their stories, supported by Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner and state Reps. Tony DeLuca and Dan Frankel. I cannot name a lawmaker that she hasn’t tried to persuade. No tangible results.
Read More
As an attorney, I am familiar with the scenario where the courts decide an issue by saying that it is a matter for the Legislature. On a constitutional basis, they are most often right. Anyone who remembers civics knows that the Legislature makes the laws and the courts interpret them, but you can’t interpret something stuck in the bowels of a fearful, legislatively constipated Harrisburg.
She has gone seven years without a good night’s sleep or a pain-free day. She once confessed to my wife that she knew that she “wasn’t fun anymore.” That it broke my heart to hear this pales in comparison with the thought that she could die because Jeffrey Jesus Romoff and his Band of Ignorant Apostles have forgotten (if they ever cared) that their decisions affect people’s lives.
Mayor Bill Peduto and Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald have proven their fealty to the God of Oakland by their inaction. They have been hiding in plain sight, only to appear when summoned to announce some minor concession, no doubt a public relations ploy to be leaned on at a later date.
A few weeks ago, Beth came into my office and said, “You know, I’m so wrapped up in this fight that I forget that I might die if it doesn’t go our way.” Unlike Mssrs. Romoff, Turzai, Fitzgerald, Peduto and the men and women of the Band of Ignorant Apostles that is the UPMC board, I can’t forget that my friend might die because they don’t care.
Robert Sebastian is a local attorney. He lives in Castle Shannon.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.