Saudi Arabia is fac­ing its big­gest dip­lo­matic cri­sis with the West since the 9/​11 at­tacks — and it is one al­most cer­tainly made by royal hands. The rea­son is that the dis­ap­pear­ance of The Wash­ing­ton Post col­um­nist Ja­mal Khashoggi looks di­rectly trace­able to the gov­ern­ment in Ri­yadh. The ev­i­dence points to Mr. Khashoggi be­ing tor­tured, killed and mu­ti­lated af­ter walk­ing into the Saudi con­sul­ate in Is­tan­bul by a hit squad who had been sent on the or­ders of the king­dom’s crown prince Mo­ham­med bin Sal­man. Ri­yadh is pre­par­ing to say Mr. Khashoggi was killed by mis­take dur­ing an in­ter­ro­ga­tion. But if it turns out that the crown prince signed off on a plan to ab­duct or even kill a critic in Is­tan­bul then it raises his des­po­tism to the level of ty­rants such as Sad­dam Hus­sein and Muam­mar Gad­dafi, who used their em­bas­sies to ter­ror­ize ex­iles.

Prince Mo­ham­med has been the power be­hind the throne in Saudi Arabia ever since his father King Sal­man be­came the coun­try’s ab­so­lute ruler in Jan­u­ary 2015. While pledg­ing to mod­ern­ize the con­ser­va­tive king­dom, the crown prince has locked up hu­man rights ac­tiv­ists and cler­i­cal crit­ics.

The crown prince is the hard­liner in the Gulf row with Qatar and the ar­chi­tect of the di­sas­trous war in neigh­bor­ing Yemen, where Saudi forces have bombed and de­lib­er­ately starved the Mid­dle East’s poor­est na­tion. He cares lit­tle for uni­ver­sal rights or the lib­eral in­ter­na­tional or­der and has been em­bold­ened by his friend­ship with Don­ald Trump, whose first for­eign trip as U.S. pres­i­dent was to Ri­yadh. It is Mr. Trump who ap­pears to be giv­ing cover to the lu­di­crous idea that a 15-man tor­ture team — which in­cluded a fo­ren­sics doc­tor — killed Mr. Khashoggi but only be­cause they got car­ried away.

Un­til now, Western gov­ern­ments and busi­nesses had mostly been will­ing to ig­nore hu­man rights is­sues. But Mr. Khashoggi’s dis­ap­pear­ance sig­naled that even care­fully ar­gued crit­i­cism about grow­ing re­pres­sion in Saudi Arabia and the ca­lam­ity in Yemen was seen as suf­fi­cient ex­cuse for mur­der. Mr. Khashoggi’s body, say the Turks, was carved up with a bone saw and smug­gled out in a black Mer­cedes van. The crown prince’s so­bri­quet MBS now sees him darkly mocked as “Mr. Bone Saw.” In Brit­ain and Amer­ica lead­ing law­mak­ers say it may be time for sanc­tions. In re­sponse the Saudis have threat­ened to wea­p­on­ize their vast oil re­serves and buy arms from Mos­cow.

Advertise with us

This lat­est ep­i­sode ought to fo­cus minds in Ri­yadh on the suit­abil­ity of the crown prince for the top job. He is of­fi­cially the heir to the throne. Only in his 30s, Mo­ham­med bin Sal­man could rule for a long time — a fu­ture that would be marked by in­sta­bil­ity if the past few years are any guide.

King Sal­man has other tal­ented sons. There are also other gifted roy­als. Prince Mo­ham­med is King Sal­man’s third crown prince. If he had any hand in the events of the past fort­night, it must be time for the House of Saud to find a fourth.