Heinz Field and the city of Pittsburgh will look spectacular under the lights when Pitt and Penn State meet for the 99th time in a prime-time telecast Saturday. An outside observer, unfamiliar with this area’s sporting landscape, might conclude that this region is a college football hotbed.

But is it? Much like the traveling carnival — here tonight, gone tomorrow — little evidence of the night before promises to remain Sunday morning because it will be the dawn of a new Steelers season.

Visit your favorite restaurant or grocery store and count the number of people wearing black and gold. Do the same on the day Pitt is playing and note the difference.

Pitt and Penn State first met on the football field in 1893, when Pennsylvania State College defeated the Western University of Pennsylvania, 32-0, at Beaver Field. Today, the series has taken on a life of its own away from the gridiron with two very argumentative fan bases and two very different playing environments.

Advertise with us

♦

In March 1999, the decision became official — Pitt Stadium, the Panthers’ home since 1925, would be razed and Pitt would play home games at Heinz Field beginning in 2001. One by one, Pitt’s trustees made brief speeches explaining the move, with one saying, “The city of Pittsburgh is our campus.”

A nice sentiment, but keep in mind that when Pitt won its  national championship in 1976, there was no parade for the team Downtown. I can’t recall a designated “Blue and Gold Day” the Friday before an important game or a pep rally at Market Square or anywhere else. You’re not likely to see signs hanging from office buildings supporting Pitt football. And don’t forget the legions of Penn State, West Virginia and Notre Dame fans in Pittsburgh, many of whom root for the Steelers on Sunday but not for Pitt on Saturday.

Two personal experiences come to mind. The publishing company for one of my books asked me to make calls to various Pittsburgh shops to gauge their interest in stocking a book about Pitt athletics. A woman at one prominent local establishment, declining my proposition, stated that it only stocked items from the Steelers, Pirates and Penguins. None from any of the “minor” teams was how she put it.

In January 2006, following publication of “100 Years of Pitt Basketball,” the publisher arranged a number of radio talk-show appearances for me. Surprisingly, one was with Amy Lawrence, then hosting a show from Oklahoma City. I thought it a bit odd, but Pitt was 17-1 at the time so it made a little sense. I should have known better; Amy only wanted to talk about the Steelers’ upcoming Super Bowl with the Seattle Seahawks.

Advertise with us

By contrast, State College hosted rousing celebratory parades along College Avenue after the Nittany Lions won national titles in 1982 and 1986. There was even a parade, with close to 50,000 spectators, after Penn State lost to Oklahoma in the Orange Bowl following the 1985 season.

Penn State fans who chortle at Pitt’s modest football attendance figures are chortling up the wrong stadium. A more accurate barometer for Pitt would be how it compares with schools in similar situations — Boston College, Temple, Cincinnati, Houston and Miami.

It’s not by coincidence that the college football stadiums with the largest seating capacities — State College; Ann Arbor, Mich.; Columbus, Ohio; and Tuscaloosa, Ala. — are in places where there is no National Football League team.

Professional sports weren’t always tops in Pittsburgh. The Steelers were football vagabonds before Three Rivers Stadium opened in 1970. They played some of their home games at Pitt Stadium during the late 1950s and for much of the 1960s.

The NFL appeals to all demographics. Pitt, like other college teams in pro towns, does not. It must rely on student and alumni support primarily, then win big to attract the community at large.

Advertise with us

♦

From 1973 through 1982, the Pitt-Penn State rivalry was as fierce and meaningful as any in the country. The buildup and tension in Pittsburgh and State College the week of the game were palpable, due in large part to the efforts of Penn State coach Joe Paterno and Johnny Majors and Jackie Sherrill at Pitt. Paterno inherited a winning program, but it did not have a national profile. He, more than any other individual, put Penn State on the map. (Too late for the 1953 Texas Christian University team, which flew to Harrisburg for its game with Penn State, thinking that was where the school was located.)

Majors and top assistant Sherrill, his eventual successor, arrived in Pittsburgh following Pitt’s 1-10 1972 season. Pitt hadn’t compiled a winning record since 1963. Majors and Sherrill did nothing less than save Pitt’s football program.

Any rivalry is at its best when both teams are very good and competing for the same honors. In college football, it becomes even more heated between the coaches because they are responsible for player acquisition, recruiting and assembling their teams without scouting and personnel departments.

Majors and Sherrill put Pitt on that college football map in quick fashion, getting the attention of its nemesis rival to the east. Tony Dorsett, Gordon Jones, Randy Holloway, Russ Grimm, Dan Marino and Bill Fralic were some of the stars Pitt attracted in those years. Penn State no longer was the only big kid on the block.

Advertise with us

Paterno was educated at Brown University, where he played quarterback and cornerback. His father’s ambition was for his son to become a lawyer. But after joining Rip Engle’s staff at Penn State, the coaching bug bit hard, and Paterno went on to become one of the best coaches in college football history.

Majors came from a decorated football family in his native Tennessee. His father had been a highly successful high school and college coach in the South. Two of Johnny’s younger brothers starred at Tennessee. Johnny finished second to Notre Dame’s Paul Hornung for the Heisman Trophy in 1956. As a head coach, he helped revive a moribund Iowa State program before accepting the Pitt job.

Sherrill was the stereotypical boy from the wrong side of the tracks who was accepted by neighborhood kids from all backgrounds. He learned to be independent at an early age, doing odd jobs for pay even when he was in grade school. He also developed a unique talent early in life — the ability not to be bullied or intimidated by anything or anybody.

Where Majors was diplomatic, Sherrill was confrontational. Majors, a gregarious storyteller, knew and understood how to charm and play the media to his and his program’s advantage. He was precisely the coach and salesman Pitt needed to revitalize its program. Sherrill, more subdued, had little time for popularity contests, adhering to a strict “If you don’t like me, that’s your problem, not mine” philosophy.

Sherill and Paterno each was a thorn in the other's side. Sherrill is the only coach whose teams defeated Penn State in successive seasons (1979 and 1980) at Beaver Stadium during Paterno's tenure, while Paterno's Nittany Lions shattered Pitt's last best chance at a national title with a stunning 48-14 win at Pitt Stadium in the 1981 season finale.

Advertise with us

Still, Paterno and Sherrill had more in common — intelligence, ambition, drive and ego — than most Penn Staters ever knew. And when two highly competitive combatants enter the same circle, there’s bound to be friction. Neither man missed a trick, always seeking an edge or advantage.

In the week leading up to the 1973 game at Beaver Stadium, with his team’s unbeaten season at stake, Paterno made sure the grass was free to grow higher in an effort to slow Pitt’s freshman sensation Dorsett. (Paterno had his own Heisman Trophy winner that year, senior John Cappelletti.) The Lions won, 35-13.

Five years later, Penn State was 10-0 and Pitt 8-2 before the regular-season finale in Happy Valley. The day before, after the Pitt team finished its light practice at Beaver Stadium, Penn State officials suspected that Pitt’s football cleats were too long. This, of course, was brought to Paterno’s attention, and the next day before the game, officials entered the Pitt locker room to inspect Pitt’s shoes. They were legal. Penn State came from behind in the fourth quarter to win, 17-10.

For his part, Sherrill, in a hotly contested recruiting battle for Dorsett, once spent an entire overnight awake in his car outside the Dorsett home, thinking a Penn State recruiter might show up at an unusual hour.

Sherrill wasn’t above a little fabrication when it came time to motivate a player. Prior to kickoff of the Pitt-Tennessee (coached by Johnny Majors) game at Knoxville in 1980, he approached senior quarterback Rick Trocano on the sideline. Trocano was from the Cleveland area. Tennessee’s quarterback was Jeff Olszewski, also a native Ohioan who had been a high school senior the same time as Trocano. Sherrill casually made reference to the fact that Majors, during the recruiting season, had noted that Olszewski was a better college prospect than Trocano. The story wasn’t true, but Trocano didn’t know that. Pitt won, 30-6.

Advertise with us

This year’s Pitt-Penn State game will be the last one played in Pittsburgh for the foreseeable future. The 100th game in the series will be staged next September at Beaver Stadium. After that, when they play again is anyone’s guess. Pitt and Penn State may not compete on the football field for a long while, but the respective fan bases can keep the rivalry alive without any games, instead exchanging barbs and insults on internet message boards or through social media.

To Pitt fans, Penn State people demonstrate a shocking degree of naivete, blind loyalists who are unable, or unwilling, to accept that any trace of scandal or corruption has ever broken through the protective cocoon that surrounds Happy Valley.

Followers of the Nittany Lions view Pitt fans as Penn State-obsessed whiners and crybabies who are simply jealous of their longer-standing success in football, along with a much larger fan base.

Both, to some extent, are correct.

Sam Sciullo Jr. (sampitt@comcast.net) is a freelance writer.