For most people, Monday’s eclipse was just something cool to see — a once- or twice-in-a-lifetime chance to watch the world go dark in the day. But in the years between 1914 and 1922, eclipses were much more. A series of eclipses during and just after World War I changed our understanding of gravity and the structure of space-time. But these discoveries weren’t easy or straightforward: It took eight expedition teams, a Pittsburgh astronomer, an international propaganda campaign and one extraordinary, forgotten woman to show us the shape of the universe we live in.

In 1911, Albert Einstein published one of his first theories of gravitation. In it, he predicted that the light from stars near the sun would be displaced, due to the sun’s gravity, by a small but noticeable angle. Under normal circumstances, that displacement would not be measurable; stars near the sun cannot be seen, because of, well, sunlight. During the totality of a solar eclipse, however, the sun is dimmed and stars in a direct line of sight passing near the edge of the sun can be seen though a telescope and photographed.

Astronomers from three continents chased eclipses in order test Einstein’s hypothesis. A total eclipse passed through Russia in 1914, and expeditions from German, Argentine and American observatories went there to photograph it. But all of the expeditions failed. The Argentines and Americans were defeated by rain, and the Germans were arrested and made prisoners of war — during the course of the expedition, World War I had been declared.

Before another attempt could be made, advances in academia changed the game. Einstein’s original prediction of the deflection of light was equal to that which Newton’s theory of gravity predicted. But in 1915, Einstein published his now-famous general theory of relativity and, according to this theory, the angle of deflection was now twice as large as Newton’s. Any new measurements now would be used to determine whether it was Newton or Einstein who was right.

Advertise with us

In 1918, the path of totality of another eclipse passed through Washington state, and a group from the Lick Observatory (near San Jose, Calif.), led by astronomer Heber Doust Curtis, took photographs. Curtis, who was on leave from the Army, measured the images and calculated the deflection of the starlight. Curtis calculated the deflection to be equal to Newton’s prediction. He announced his result at a meeting of the Pacific Astronomical Society. In London, his boss, W.W. Campbell, the director of the Lick, announced Curtis’ result at meeting of the Royal Astronomical Society.

Campbell was not in London just to deliver Curtis’ findings. World War I had just ended, and as governments were trying to sort out how to treat the defeated Germany and sustain peace, international scientists were negotiating their own academic terms of surrender. Fritz Haber, a German Nobel Prize-winning chemist, had developed poison gases and overseen their use in battle, and sentiment in the international scientific community was extraordinarily anti-German. Curtis was in London on his way to a meeting in Europe to organize against allowing German scientists to participate in scientific meetings after the war ended.

Meanwhile, astronomers in Britain were trying to do just the opposite. Not wanting to lose the numerous contributions of German scientists, the English were in search of a friendly figurehead to be the face of German science and to cool international academic tensions. Einstein, who was already famous and had signed a public letter opposing the war, seemed just the man for the job. To demonstrate the value of British cooperation with German science, British astronomers decided to test his general theory of relativity during an eclipse in 1919 — and hope his new prediction was right. They sent expeditions to Brazil and to the island of Principe off the west coast of Africa, and presented their results in the summer of that year.

The results were controversial. Measurements from photographs shot by one of the three telescopes supported Newton. A second telescope supported neither Newton nor Einstein, and a third supported Einstein. The English astronomers concluded that Einstein's 1915 prediction had been confirmed.

The Lick Observatory’s results, confirming Newton’s value, might have changed the conversation considerably. But they were nowhere to be found. They had been announced but never published.

Advertise with us

Curtis, who by this time had left the Lick to become director of the Allegheny Observatory in Pittsburgh, wanted to know why. He wrote to Campell urging publication of his results contradicting Einstein’s theory. But Campbell was a careful man. He had assigned Adelaide Hobe, an assistant at the Lick, to check all of Curtis’ calculations. Hobe had a degree in physics from Berkeley, although on her college transcript some incredulous administrator had entered her major as “home economics.” She had been hired at the Lick as an assistant and funded by the Carnegie Foundation, but, because she was a woman, she was not allowed to become an official astronomer.

Campbell wrote back to Curtis that Hobe had shown his calculations to be like “random numbers” and advised Curtis to let it go.

Curtis obliged. He went on to become director of the observatory at the University of Michigan, and never again, to our knowledge, libeled a major scientific theory. Campbell became president of the University of California. Einstein, you know about. Adelaide Hobe retired into the obscurity she had never escaped, her work hidden behind that of famous men. And, in 1922, Lick astronomers traveled to one more eclipse, this one in Australia — where they confirmed Einstein’s theory.

Madelyn Glymour is a data analyst and Clark Glymour is an alumni university professor at Carnegie Mellon University.