What do you know?

One part greeting, one part conversation starter, this question is at the heart of student-teacher interaction. Effective teachers work to measure and to bridge the distance between what students should know and what they don’t. Every autumn, our students are the same age; every year, we teachers are older. And with each new school year, a knowledge gap expands. On the first day of class I ask myself: Just who are these kids?

Mark Bauerlein provides some clues in his best-seller “The Dumbest Generation: How the Digital Age Stupefies Young Americans and Jeopardizes Our Future.” There are similarities between his findings and my classroom observations. For example:

• Today’s students are frighteningly narcissistic, evidenced by myriad expressions of material culture, such as tattoos, piercings, Facebook pages, Pinterest postings, self-indulgent blogs and ubiquitous selfies. Mr. Bauerlein’s work underscores the collateral damage such narrow-mindedness can inflict on academic achievement: “The insulated mindset of individuals who know precious little history and civics and never read a book or visit a museum is fast becoming a common, shame-free condition … in their minds, a-literacy and anti-intellectualism pose no career obstacles, and they have no shame attached.”

Advertise with us

• While today’s students have ready access to technology and expend a great deal of personal resources purchasing and maintaining it, they tend to be bottom feeders when they access the Internet, visiting shopping sites, social media sites and, sadly, pornography sites with much greater frequency than they visit, say, the Louvre, the Smithsonian or the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Mr. Bauerlein writes: “Instead of opening young American minds to the stores of civilization and science, technology has contracted their horizons to themselves, to the social scene around them. An anti-intellectual outlook prevails in their leisure lives, quashing the lessons of school, and instead of producing a knowledgeable and querulous young mind, the youth culture of American society yields an adolescent consumer enmeshed in juvenile matters and secluded from adult realities.”

• Students are willing victims of a consumer culture that emphasizes trivial social interactions masquerading as critical communication. Echoing this point, Mr. Bauerlein observes that same consumer culture disguised as intellectual achievement and attainment: “With a thousand marketers and stores to entice them, and popular commentators backing them up, teens and 20-year-olds hear the book-pushing voices of teachers and librarians as pesky whispers.” Where once studying the words of revolutionaries such as Christ, Gandhi and King might have inspired and radicalized students, kids now follow, sheep-like, the marketers’ bleats.

I refuse to buy into the pop culture myth that kids’ access to technology builds better students. The evidence I read in the declining quality of student work screams this. Mr. Bauerlein also sees through myth, saying, “People who do notice a spreading dumbness and proclaim it run the risk of being labeled a curmudgeon.”

Call me Professor Curmudgeon. Based on what I experience as a professor, and contrary to what the purveyors of so-called educational technology would have us believe, today’s students might know less than their predecessors. Every semester I encounter more students in need of tutoring, remediation and review. I fight a strong temptation to dumb things down.

Wanting to assess the current state of student knowledge, I deployed a three-step diagnostic involving about 60 students over two school years. Maybe you’d like to play along. You don’t need a computer, just a pencil, paper and a clock. Take a minute to write everything that comes to mind when you hear or see each of the following:

Advertise with us

• 1776

• Picture of the star and crescent

• Lindsay Lohan

The findings are revealing.

Sixty-six percent of students responded to the 1776 inquiry in typical fashion, offering words that evoke ideologies, such as liberty, freedom and revolution. This group provided proper nouns, including Washington, Jefferson and Franklin and Philadelphia, Boston and Yorktown. Students listed relevant objects, such as the Declaration of Independence and Liberty Bell.

Advertise with us

But 33 percent responded to the 1776 inquiry in ways one might find deeply troubling. Some examples:

• No technology

• A code or password

• Something important in history?

• Old

Advertise with us

• Important date?

• Math

• Year someone was born

In the fall of 2013, zero students identified the star and crescent as the symbol for Islam. Some described it literally: moon, star, crescent. Some attempted to divine its meaning: happiness, together, tranquility. Others made literal interpretations: nighttime, coloring book image, cool tattoo idea. In fact, 90 percent of students identified the symbol for Islam as a neat idea for personal ornamentation.

The numbers were only slightly improved in the fall of 2014, perhaps because three Saudi students took the test.

Advertise with us

Also in 2013 and 2014, nearly all students identified Lindsay Lohan as a troubled actress. Students listed her movie credits, arrests, relationships and relapses, describing her as a star, a train wreck and ruined. Students had more to say about Lindsay Lohan than one minute allowed, and I had to ask them to stop writing after time expired.

What to make of all of this?

I contend that the Web stifles our kids and captures them in a never-ending cycle of immaturity, wherein technology isn’t an instrument for self-improvement but a perpetual-motion machine cranking out junk.

Let’s be fair: Young people have always placed great emphasis on matters they perceive to be important. In the 1970s, for example, my friends and I knew much more about music and cars than economics and technology. But we didn’t have fingertip access to the Library of Alexandria. Mr. Bauerlein supports my observation: “Adolescents have always wasted their time and chances, of course, but the Dumbest Generation has raised the habit into a brash and insistent practice. No cohort in human history has opened such a fissure between its material conditions and its intellectual attainments. None has experienced so many technological enhancements and yielded so little mental progress.”

One may lament a loss of shared national identity evidenced by students’ responses to the 1776 question and wonder how someone was graduated from an American high school without this four-digit collection of numbers having some resonance. One may question how a cohort of post-9/​11 college students could fail to identify the symbol of one of the world’s great religions. One can only guess at the amount of misspent time following the Twitter feeds of untalented and troubled starlets. But lamentation and guesswork stifle evolution and won’t be of much use to teachers working against the backdrop of a rapidly changing cultural and technological landscape.

Advertise with us

Therefore, I believe I have some useful advice for all of us who teach:

• Work harder and keep kids’ best interests at heart.

• Assume nothing and avoid falling prey to a cultural myth that suggests today’s students are somehow superior to their predecessors.

• Don’t try to be cool. Some things that worked in the past still work today. So tell your students about their Waterloo or their Vietnam. Teach them that these are the times that will try their souls. Emphasize the value inherent in attempting to perform the anatomical impossibilities of simultaneously keeping one’s eye on the ball, one’s shoulder to the wheel and one’s nose to the grindstone.

• Avoid the shallow and cosmetic: Don’t sport a tattoo that miscalculates a symbol’s power. Don’t follow Ms. Lohan on Twitter or like her on Facebook.

Advertise with us

• By example, illustrate the ways in which education can transform lives.

• Employ technology when it benefits students. Don’t use technology or require its use simply because it exists or makes your job easier. Students need teachers who do more than show movies and make PowerPoint presentations. Know your stuff.

• Avoid the constant seduction of the new and the powerful lure of a consumer culture spun out of control.

Ed Stankowski (edward.stankowski@laroche.edu) is a Mount Washington resident and professor of English at La Roche College.