The three writers here are part of the Pittsburgh Civic Design Coalition: www.pghdesigncoalition.org
A master plan for HOW Pittsburgh will grow
ERIC R. OSTH: We are well placed for the new world of scarce fossil fuels -- if we make the right moves now.
My grandparents grew up in cities. They grew up in some remarkable urban communities, playing along friendly streets, walking to corner markets and schools, and riding on public transit. When they were married, like so many others, they fled the city for new-growth suburbs to raise their children. What is interesting is that all four of my grandparents loved cities -- while my parents, who grew up in the suburbs, are still learning to love them.
I see neglected areas of Pittsburgh and I fear for their future. Through this lens I see that Pittsburgh is like my parents -- it must learn to love city life and embrace it. So the questions are: Why should we do this? And more importantly, how should we do this?
The issue of "why" is going to be answered for us in the not-so-distant future. Global warming is upon us and at the same time, fossil fuels are growing scarce -- a scarcity that will make an automobile-focused suburban life unfeasible. Therefore, city life is in our children's future. For many cities in the United States, the crisis has already begun.
Right now, Pittsburgh is a great place to live. We have a long list of characteristics for the future that will make it a desirable place for living and for business that includes: existing strong residential neighborhoods, pedestrian-scaled neighborhood centers, neighborhood schools, active parks and a strong and effective public transit system to move us around, rivers to move goods and services, local manufacturing and food production and plenty of water.
Therefore, we know Pittsburgh will grow -- and it will change.
The issue of "how" we should grow is critical. We must not look into the future and merely hope for survival. Rather, we should look into the future with a focus on evolution as an opportunity to reconstruct our relationship with Pittsburgh.
Through forward-thinking, open and participatory master planning, we can envision a future for Pittsburgh that sets the table for new growth in a flexible, careful, sustainable manner with remarkable individual character. We can build stronger neighborhoods and vibrant new places within the city by simply connecting our ideals and our values with the places in which we live and work.
In the past, these mechanisms have allowed certain neighborhoods to flourish. The rising neighborhood around Market Square, the South Side and SouthSide Works, the burgeoning Cultural District and the revitalization of the East Liberty neighborhood show us that we can evolve.
And in this visioning for Pittsburgh through the next decade, we must not ask what we want for Pittsburgh, but instead ask ourselves: "What do we value for Pittsburgh?" Only through this discussion can we truly embrace city life.
Eric R. Osth is a principal at Urban Design Associates and vice president of the Pittsburgh chapter of the American Institute of Architects.
Fair, clear and equal rules for all developers
ANNE SWAGER: The city's planning process must be a hotbed of professionalism.
Elected officials are all about new projects and programs which can help the citizens of their cities. Nothing is more visible than "bricks and mortar." The design and construction of new buildings and developments is all about jobs, from the design by an architect to the construction by construction workers to the eventual new businesses that will occupy the new development.
It is also not uncommon to see a mayor lay off a good part of the city Planning Department and bring new people into his office in the name of "economic development." While this sounds good, it is inherently flawed.
Cities need a logical plan for how the city can develop, followed by a system that ensures that everyone is treated fairly. The developer needs a predictable process with clear rules. Citizens who have already invested in the city by either buying a home or owning a business are entitled to have their investment protected. Everyone is entitled to a predictable open process. The visioning, planning and zoning necessary to ensure the plan is carried out is the purview of the Planning Department.
To create a new development in the city, a developer has to submit his plans to several different entities and go through a fairly lengthy approval process. This process is guided and augmented by various commissions and boards all of whom advise both the mayor and City Council.
At the beginning of each mayor's term there is always a call for ordinary citizens to volunteer for one commission or another. Most mayors promise to populate these many different boards and commissions with people of both genders, different racial and ethnic backgrounds, and different age groups.
Many hard-working and diligent volunteers make up the commissions responsible for the physical attributes of our city. They look at such things as signage, historic areas, street lighting standards, sidewalk paving, public art, and of course buildings both new and old. We have the Art Commission, the Planning Board, the Zoning Hearing Board, and the Historic Review Commission all dealing with issues that effect the livability of our city residents, businesses, and visitors. The purview that these commissions cover is very large and often they deal with very challenging issues.
A developer has a team of lawyers, engineers, architects and landscape architects working together to help the development get planned, permitted and built. The city needs equally qualified people in their Planning Department and on their commissions charged with improving the city.
Diversity should be one goal for the boards, authorities, and commissions of the city. The other goal should be highly qualified individuals who are well matched to their duties. The rules and regulations that govern project development are highly technical. With ever changing technology -- like LEDs for lighting -- these rules and regulations must be interpreted and sometimes modified when necessary. Understanding the implications of materials, mass, lighting, etc. are best left in the hands of architects, landscape architects and engineers.
The cities we think of as successful like Seattle, Chicago, Boston and Portland, Ore., all have a strong planning ethic which has been informed by professionals in the industry as well as meaningful citizen input. Visioning the city's physical future should involve everyone. Interpreting the resulting rules and understanding the nuances of proposals is best left to the qualified professionals who make their livelihood in planning and design.
A plentitude of rules is not a deterrent to development. A process clouded by inconsistencies and a lack of standards is.
Anne Swager is executive director of AIA Pittsburgh (aswager@aiapgh.org).
The clean-water imperative -- and a better, greener solution
VIVIAN LOFTNESS: Let's lead the nation in landscaping our way out of the storm-sewer crisis -- to become a truly green city.
Between $2 billion and $4 billion in scarce resources will be needed to address the storm-sewer crisis in Pittsburgh. While Pittsburgh's population is half of 100 years ago, our storm runoff is at historic highs due to increased paving for parking lots and roads, and of course climate change.
The uncontrolled runoff during each storm has resulted in sewage overflows right into our rivers, and those of many older cities -- causing EPA to mandate money be spent (in budget-busting amounts). Yet the only solution on the table is a conventional big-pipe solution (actually two big pipes) that will tear up our streets, our sidewalks and street trees -- and leave a city poor and scarred.
We have a strategic opportunity to landscape our way out of the storm-sewer crisis, to create a world-class city and create a new green "export" industry.
Imagine every drop of rain is captured by new gardens and landscaped surfaces. Imagine tree-lined streets, rebuilt porous sidewalks edged by colorful plantings and parking lots defined by green swales and tree canopies. Imagine green roofs and connected parks, watersheds that are micro "waterfalls in the rain" and riverfronts that are ribbons of indigenous plants. Combined with investment in water-conserving fixtures, these investments in greening our city will eliminate storm water runoff, and ensure that our relined sewers can continue to meet the cities demand for generations.
We will need to be visionary, to convince the EPA that we can landscape our way out of a crisis, especially with public investment in water conserving fixtures throughout the city -- all at lower first cost and greater gains in quality of life. The mayor of Pittsburgh does not hold sole responsibility for this project, but whoever occupies the office must take a leading role.
Neighborhoods in Denver enjoy a water-supply system distributed in a "daylit" or open canal, which provides joggers and bicyclists with a green park access to the city center. Chicago's pervasive commitment to green roofs has already reduced storm runoff, even with less than 5 percent of the roofs greened to date. The University of Virginia has shifted its investments in retention tanks to lakes, to reduced hard surfacing, and to diverse landscaping -- eliminating the modern flooding of Charlottesville while brilliantly enhancing their campus.
Pittsburgh has the potential to lead the nation in city-beautiful surface solutions to the storm/sewer challenges through water conservation, on-site water management and water management through landscape -- a solution set that generates new professional and industrial growth for our region.
Vivian Loftness is university professor of architecture at Carnegie Mellon University, where she served as head of the School of Architecture from 1994 to 2004 (loftness@cmu.edu).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.