Mental illness and related social disabilities present an age-old spectrum of social disorders — from irrational violence to unsanitary public spaces — for which each generation struggles to find an appropriate response, balancing individual liberties and the general welfare.
So it’s really unfortunate when a public official like Erin Dalton says “We don’t throw people in jail,” while avoiding the crucial questions (“In Pittsburgh, we closed encampments without handcuffs,” Sept. 10). Those questions are: When laws are broken, should mental illness be treated as a get-out-of-jail-free card? and What are our principles for involuntary commitment of persons with anti-social behaviors?
No one argues for simply throwing people in jail, but it is not compassionate to ignore those of diminished social capacity who may be a threat to themselves and others. We can applaud Ms. Dalton’s efforts to house the unhoused humanely, while recognizing that providing free public housing is a moral hazard that can never be a comprehensive solution to mental illness or to homelessness.
The problem is not that taxpaying citizens are uncaring. It is that mental illness leading to antisocial behavior has always been — and remains — a difficult problem.
There is no free lunch and no simple solution. Implicit accusations of heartlessness against citizens seeking answers can only impede the search for compassionate and workable solutions.
John Kaufmann
Murrysville




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.