As Sen. Dan Laughlin suggested, redistricting has always been political (“Let the parties redraw the congressional map,” Aug. 29). His proposed solution, allowing leaders of the two major parties to take turns drawing district lines, assumes those parties and their leaders are the central players in our democracy, with no voice for independent or third party voters.
And in his proposed fantasy football game, voters, no matter what party they belong to, would be bystanders watching leaders carve up the map to benefit their top players.
No other major democracy allows party leaders a significant role in redistricting. Independent redistricting commissions, composed of citizens with no personal stake in district lines and no vested interest in pleasing party leaders, can break the current two party doom loop and provide less need for high court intervention.
Laughlin suggests that party leaders would decide on parameters before drawing district lines. Mapping standards should be in law.
A new national poll shows 82% of Americans prefer independent redistricting commissions. We can’t take politics out of the process, but we can stop allowing political leaders to referee their own games.
Carol Kuniholm
Exton, Pa.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.