The first obligation of a government is to protect the health and safety of its citizens. Before embarking on any new law or initiative, a government must first assess whether that action, no matter how worthwhile or morally sound, is consistent with its first obligation.

We can argue whether Trump’s aggressive approach to deporting immigrants stands on solid legal and moral ground but does that action endanger the health and safety of our citizens? If his action has generated the foreseeable vigorous response from the immigrant community and others and that response can be handled and contained by local and state officials, then it meets the first test.

If, as the president seems to believe, even at the earliest and more restricted stage of this program it requires the military takeover of our cities, it clearly fails this test. Prohibition of the 1920s and 30s may have been a fine idea, but its enforcement led to chaos and lawlessness.

Michael C. Joyce

Mt. Lebanon