In his recent op-ed published Feb. 3rd, David Butler downplays the threat of Trump tariff policies (“Tariffs work — if they’re reasonable, but not if they’re extreme”). His explanation that tariffs can be benign is flawed because the USA he envisages no longer exists.
Back when presidents from Washington through Eisenhower applied tariffs, the USA was filled with consumer goods producers of all kinds. When, for example, imported clothing became more expensive and the supply diminished due to a tariff, US producers picked up the slack, supply rebalanced with demand and price volatility was held in check.
Today, the large US makers of sheets, shirts, socks, t-shirts, coats, hats, shoes, dresses or handbags are gone. We import common groceries like avocados, bananas, and salmon. And don’t even start with electronic devices.
Over the past few decades, we’ve seen the amputation of production capacity in the USA, making us virtual trade slaves to countries like China, Mexico, Japan and Vietnam.
Today, if the supply of socks is curtailed in a trade dispute, Americans will pay inflated prices for what socks we can find and may have to go barefoot for a time. To make matters worse, if USA industries try to rebuild sock production capacity, who will they hire to do the work when the available cheap labor has been deported? The Trump tariff and immigration policies can’t make America great again.
Nickolas Certo
Troy Hill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.