The op-ed advocating that government take an active role in improving public health (“What governments must do for public health for everyone’s good,” Sept. 28) offers a breathtaking litany of great ideas: “tax hamburgers to subsidize spinach … encourage healthy eating … use food taxes to subsidize healthy foods ... subsidize gym memberships … use the power of big government to ‘encourage healthy eating.’”

Still, brilliant as the writer is, his memory is short. The biggest effort the government made to control the nation’s eating habits was the “food pyramid” that indiscriminately demonized fat and sanctified carbohydrates. He forgets that this coincided exactly with the national rise in obesity and perpetrated dietary myths that persist to this day, although every doctor and nutritionist long ago recognized them to be 100% wrong.

The reason they persist is that, for decades, the vaunted “power of big government” was used to ruthlessly quash any competing theories and destroy the careers and reputations of anyone who dared question the orthodoxy.

Now he proposes that we go beyond recommendations to subsidies to what will surely morph into mandates. Thank goodness there’s no chance they could possibly be wrong this time!

Advertise with us

Vincent Finizio

Ross