The Allegheny County court administration recently suspended Magisterial District Judge Xander Orenstein from hearing arraignments after they imposed nonmonetary bond on a criminal suspect who subsequently absconded.
In doing so, the court administration disenfranchises me and every Magisterial District 05-3-10 voter by summarily denying us what we bargained for when we voted in the 2021 elections: a magisterial district judge with the same authority, discretion, and independence as their 45 MDJ peers throughout Allegheny County. Judge Orenstein’s values generally and their view on monetary bail specifically appealed to voters, like me, and caused us to vote for them in 2021.
We did not vote for an MDJ to be a judicial rubber stamp for warrants sought by police. We did not vote for an MDJ who would, with rote thoughtlessness, condemn persons accused of crimes to the Allegheny County Jail because they cannot afford to post monetary bond. If we voters dislike how Judge Orenstein discharges the duties of their judgeship — as plenty do — then we will vote accordingly in 2027.
Until then, absent credible allegations of unethical or criminal conduct, we voters of Magisterial District 05-3-10 deserve our fully empowered magisterial district judge.
Robert Helwig
Polish Hill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.