In “Preliminary Allegheny County data ‘a stark reminder that we’re not doing enough’ to combat Black maternal deaths” (Mar. 25), Hanna Webster and Anya Litvak incorrectly read the data they themselves supply. The data shown simply do not support the conclusion that race is the cause of the poor maternal outcomes.

Rather, it indicates that being a Medicaid recipient instead of being privately insured (regardless of race) is the controlling factor in maternal deaths. It is my opinion that erroneously blaming race for a discrepancy unjustly adds fuel to the fire fracturing our nation.

I also want to point out an additional error. The editorial “To address Black maternal mortality, recruit more Black caregivers” (Mar. 29) cites a 2020 study in stating that the trend in Black maternal deaths “reliably reverses when the doctors treating the patients are also Black.”

Not so! The study concludes that “physician racial concordance is associated with a significant improvement in mortality for Black infants.” It also concludes that “We find no significant improvement in maternal mortality when birthing mothers share race with their physician.”

Advertise with us

Richard Winschel

Mt. Lebanon