The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial board ignores facts and reality by supporting Gov. Josh Shapiro’s plan to bail out mass transit bureaucracies (“Shapiro transit funding plan is good for everyone,” Mar. 27).
First, the editorial board applauded his proposal to divert more state tax dollars to Pennsylvania’s failing transit agencies, calling it a “boost … [for] an essential government service.”
Interestingly, this same editorial board referred to the Lifeline Scholarship Program as “a bad idea … [that] would divert money needed by the public school systems.” This transit bailout does exactly what the editorial board called a “bad idea”: It funnels $1.5 billion away from public schools.
The proposal diverts money from the Tax for Education, the sales tax originally dedicated to public education. (The editorial board euphemistically calls this “shifting funds.”)
Mass transit ridership is down 40%. Costs are up, but agencies have refused to adjust spending or address safety. According to the Post-Gazette, empty SEPTA and PRT buses are more “essential” than lower-income students trying to escape failing schools.
Pennsylvania mass transit agencies are already more reliant on state taxpayers than most — to the tune of $2.2 billion from taxes and charges to drivers — and less reliant on fares or local counties that supposedly benefit. Shapiro’s bailout is a blank check (with no strings attached) to a failing transit system at the expense of public schools and rural taxpayers.
I encourage the Post-Gazette editorial board to reexamine its definition of a “bad idea.”
Nathan Benefield
Harrisburg, PA
Mr. Benefield is a senior vice president of the Commonwealth Foundation





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.