If there is any such thing as a “just war,” the combatants must practice proportionality in the force used against each other, and they must avoid harming non-combatants. While Hamas clearly violated most just war principles, it is Israel that is committing the most flagrant violations since October 7.

Total Palestinian deaths are approaching thirty times the number of Israeli deaths in this conflict. By comparison, according to figures provided by The National WW2 Museum, total civilian and military deaths among enemy countries in World War 2 were less than total Allied deaths, even including the deaths caused by the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The Allies were responsible for proportionately far fewer deaths in World War Two than the Israelis are now.

There are those of us who believe that war can never be just, but that does not absolve combatants from being judged against just war principles. Israel is killing its enemies in far greater numbers, relative to its own losses, than the Allies did in all of World War 2.

Israel’s response to the horrific attack of October 7 has been disproportionate and has indiscriminately harmed non-combatants. It has lost any right to claim that it is fighting a just war.

Bill Vandivier
Point Breeze