We are Pittsburgh’s homeless healthcare providers, who have expertise in providing medical care to people experiencing homelessness in shelters and on the streets. This letter was drafted by eighteen doctors, nurses, nurse practitioners and social workers hailing from five different healthcare agencies in Allegheny County. (This commentary reflects our personal views, not necessarily the views of our employer institutions.)
We are writing, on behalf of the patients we serve, to express our concern about the city’s recently announced “Code Blue Action Plan” and urge the county to implement a winter shelter that is open every night.
For many years Pittsburgh has had an emergency winter shelter at Smithfield United Church of Christ, open from Nov. 15 to March 15 from 7 p.m. to 7 a.m. Hundreds of people relied on this shelter throughout winter to escape freezing and dangerous temperatures. The shelter, with all its imperfections, served as a reliable place for someone with no other options to sleep safely for the night.
This year the Smithfield winter shelter is not opening. While we applaud the opening of Second Avenue Commons and other more permanent options for those experiencing homelessness, the need for an emergency winter shelter remains. Our current shelters and overflow locations are full, and approximately 200 people are currently sleeping outside.
The plan to open a “severe weather” shelter when temperatures fall to below 26 degrees is insufficient. Frostbite, hypothermia and even death can occur at temperatures above 26 degrees. Hypothermia is actually more likely to occur when temperatures cycle above and below 32 degrees in the context of wet weather, as people may get wet during the day and experience freezing temperatures at night.
In addition, living outside in cold weather puts folks at significant risk of exacerbation of their chronic physical and mental health conditions. It is also not realistic for people experiencing homelessness to track daily announcements to know if they will have a warm place to sleep that night.
We do not suggest that Smithfield is the best permanent option and are committed to working with the county to support other sites. We ask that planning for next winter begin as soon as possible, with a plan in place by July 2024.
In the meantime, whether at Smithfield or another site, we urge the county to immediately reopen a nightly winter shelter to protect the health and well-being of our neighbors experiencing homelessness.
Max Hurwitz, D.O.
Patrick Perri, M.D.
Jim Withers, MD
Anita Leon-Jhong, MD
Madeleine Lipshie-Williams, MD
Mary Sligh, CRNP
Mary Catherine Clarke, RN
Anthonia Sellu, LCSW
Jack Todd Wahrenberger, MD, MPH
Danielle Schnauber Jones, CRNP
Janice Kochik, CRNP
Emily Powell, MSN, RN
Justin Groteleuschen, DSW, LSW
Anna Marie White, MD
Maisie Taibbi, RN
Deklerk Ngankam, MD
Lisa D. Stanford, PhD, ABPP
Robert W. Hickey, MD





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.