Lost amidst the defense team’s arguments during the penalty phase of the synagogue massacre trial, and indeed among nearly all the commentary, has been any serious examination of the death penalty’s efficacy as a tool of criminal justice.
Without minimizing the moral and spiritual aspects of the issue in any way, and with full recognition of and respect for the shattered lives of the victims’ families and friends, survivors and the community at large, it seems to me that anyone faced with such an awesome decision as sentencing another human being to death should also, and perhaps more importantly, be made to address the following:
Do death sentences actually deter future violent crimes, including anti-Semitic attacks? Is death necessarily the worst punishment a convicted murderer might wish to receive? Does the death penalty save money compared to lifetime incarceration? Does the termination of a murderer’s life provide closure to families and friends of the victims?
A fifth question, though not relevant to this particular case, is whether, in the history of capital punishment, only factually guilty individuals have been executed.
If the answer to one or more of these questions is “No,” then we need to be asking ourselves, as a society, what we’re really doing, and why. If nothing else, let’s have the collective honesty to call capital punishment what it really is: state-sanctioned vengeance.
Ben Wecht
Regent Square





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.